The 2018-19 season marked a turning point for the New York Islanders.
Under head coach Barry Trotz, fresh off a Stanley Cup win in Washington, the Isles stunned their fans and prognosticators, finishing with 103 points – their best regular-season mark since the dynasty era of the early 1980s. That season symbolized a cultural shift for the franchise, instilling the structured, defensive-first identity that carried them to multiple playoff runs.
The remnants of that team’s identity have stuck around in the way people on the outside view the team, but six years later, only six players remain from that roster: Anders Lee, Mathew Barzal, Adam Pelech, Ryan Pulock, Scott Mayfield, and Casey Cizikas. It may not seem that long ago, but the fact that the home opener was at Barclays Center in Brooklyn is a reminder of just how much has changed both on and off the ice for the franchise since that remarkable regular season that culminated in home ice in the playoffs, and a sweep of the Penguins—no reason to bring up what came next.
Lee, the captain, continues to embody the Islanders’ identity as a net-front presence and leader in the room. Barzal, then a budding star in just his second full NHL season, remains the team’s most dynamic offensive talent, though his role has evolved with linemates and injuries over time. On the back end, Pelech and Pulock, once the backbone of Trotz’s defense, are still important pieces — though injuries and inconsistency have taken some shine off their reputations in recent years. Cizikas, the heartbeat of the fourth line, remains a fan favorite, providing energy and grit just no longer strictly on the “Identity Line.”
The rest of that roster has turned over, a reminder of how quickly the NHL changes. Robin Lehner, who shared the Jennings Trophy in goal, was a one-year wonder, as was veteran winger Valtteri Filppula. Jordan Eberle was left unprotected in the 2021 expansion draft, Brock Nelson was traded last March, and Josh Bailey, Johnny Boychuk, Matt Martin, and Cal Clutterbuck have all retired.
Leo Komarov is off somewhere being Uncle Leo. Thomas Hickey is a star hockey analyst. Michael Dal Colle is off to the KHL. Devon Toews has lifted Lord Stanley in Colorado. Nick Leddy was claimed off waivers from San Jose. Anthony Beauvillier continues his career in DC. Trotz is trying to build his own winner as the GM of the Nashville Predators. And so it goes …
Fast forward to today, and the landscape of the organization has shifted dramatically. Trotz is gone, and his trusted assistant, Lane Lambert, was replaced midway through the 2023-24 season by Patrick Roy, a fiery Hall of Famer whose uptempo style is a stark contrast to Trotz’s rigid defensive system. Lou Lamoriello has also moved on, with Mathieu Darche stepping in as general manager, ushering in an era of transparency and fan engagement that the franchise hasn’t seen in decades.
For the Islanders, the six holdovers serve as a living link between the most successful modern chapter of the franchise and the present. As new management ushers in a new era, Lee, Barzal, Pelech, Pulock, Mayfield, and Cizikas remain as reminders of how far the Isles once came and how much further they hope to go.