An aerial view shows the home of James Goehring in the foreground and the Nevel residence across Emlenton Clintonville Road in the background. Investigators say Goehring shot and killed his neighbor on Wednesday before taking his own life inside his house. Gavin Fish/EYT Media.

SCRUBGRASS TOWNSHIP, Pa. (EYT) – A 52-year-old man has been identified as the shooter in Thursday’s murder-suicide that claimed the life of his 44-year-old neighbor following what investigators describe as a long-running property dispute.

A woman was fatally shot while mowing her lawn along Emlenton Clintonville Road on Thursday in what investigators say was a murder-suicide stemming from a long-running dispute between the victim and her alleged assailant.

Jamie Nevel, 44, was found dead on her property on the south side of the road with multiple gunshot wounds, according to Pennsylvania State Police. Troopers responded to the scene, about a mile west of Oneida Valley Road, after receiving a report of a body. Nevel was pronounced dead at the scene.

The shooter was identified as James Goehring, 52, who lived directly across Emlenton Clintonville Road from Nevel. Venango County Coroner Christina Rugh released Goehring’s identity on Saturday after notifying his sister.

According to the State Police, troopers surrounded Goehring’s house on Thursday night but received no response. A search warrant was granted, and a PSP tactical unit entered the residence, where they found Goehring dead in his living room from a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the head.

Venango County Coroner Christina Rugh confirmed Nevel as the victim, adding that an autopsy was performed at the Erie County Coroner’s Office by Dr. Todd Luckasevic. Nevel’s cause of death was determined to be gunshot wounds to the chest, abdomen, and pelvis.

The dispute between the Nevels and Goehring appears to have centered on property boundaries. Neighbors said Goehring insisted that the land directly across the street from his home belonged to him, despite public records showing otherwise. A parcel viewer search shows Goehring owned 0.28 acres on the north side of Emlenton Clintonville Road. The Nevels own 5.34 acres on the south side, including a section that extends west in front of Goehring’s property.

Neighbors described Goehring as increasingly unstable in recent years.

“He was Looney Tunes,” one neighbor said, noting that Goehring had placed surveillance cameras all over the outside of his home. The neighbor said they had to install a privacy screen in their backyard to avoid being watched.

Another neighbor described him as paranoid and said he frequently watched his camera feeds. The neighbor said he had become even more combative after the death of his wife in 2022. According to that neighbor, the Nevels told him they had contacted the Pennsylvania State Police several times about Goehring but were told there was nothing authorities could do.

State Police confirmed Goehring had “previous issues” with Nevel and her husband.

According to troopers, the investigation remains ongoing.

The PSP’s Major Case Team is handling the case.

RELATED STORIES

Murder-Suicide in Rural Venango County Tied to Property Line Disagreement, Neighbors Say