Title: Canada After America: A Strategy for Prosperity in a Changed WorldAuthors: Ricardo Hausmann and Eric ProtzerGenre: Non-fictionPublisher: Sutherland House BooksPages: 120

Harvard University economists Ricardo Hausmann and Eric Protzer offer a short but powerful prescription for Canada’s future in an age of American decline.

Canada After America: A Strategy for Prosperity in a Changed World draws from the authors’ research at the Harvard Growth Lab and is the focus of the 2026 McGill Max Bell Lectures.

It presumes a future where Canadians can no longer count on the United States as a reliable trading partner. The deep political polarization that now defines American dysfunction requires Canada to distance itself and diversify its economic relationships.

Open this photo in gallery:

“Canada can no longer organize its economic future around the assumption that privileged access to the American market is permanent, predictable and politically secure,” the authors write. “It needs a post-American economy, not in the sense of an economy without America, but in the sense of an economy no longer centred so completely on America that a hostile U.S. administration can threaten its prosperity at will.”

“The task is not to abandon the United States. It is to stop being hostage to it.”

While Prime Minister Mark Carney’s government is pursuing exactly that strategy, Hausmann and Protzer believe he and all Canadians need to go much further.

Diversification begins by providing the infrastructure needed to ship Canada’s abundant natural resources to overseas markets – a task that federal and provincial governments are undertaking.

But this country’s greatest asset, the authors assert, is our population: well-educated and living in relatively clean, safe, diverse and peaceful communities. Such an urban, productive society should make it possible for Canadians to develop high-value products that can be competitively manufactured and profitably exported.

‘Canada’s in America’s shadow’: In new book, U.S. author Paul Theroux tries to tell Canada’s story

Noting that Canada is already a successful exporter of software, the authors focus on three other areas ripe for expansion: pharmaceuticals, medical devices and aerospace. But in these and other areas where Canada could expand its economy – such as film, finance and advanced business services – government policies offer incentives to emerging businesses without supporting their growth into substantial enterprises. The authors advocate for a tax system that rewards success at all levels.

In short, Hausmann and Protzer call for a federally directed industrial policy, the kind that Liberal governments have practised from the days of Pierre Trudeau to the days of Justin Trudeau. An alternative approach, employed by former Conservative prime minster Stephen Harper and advocated for by current party leader Pierre Poilievre, would be to lower taxes, slash regulations and then let market forces choose winners and losers.

Both sides would agree with the authors’ focus on a competitive advantage that is at risk of being lost in Canada, and a competitive disadvantage that must be corrected.

The competitive advantage is that, until quite recently, Canada supported robust levels of immigration. This country has a long-standing tradition of bringing in large numbers of skilled workers who contribute to the economy. But during Justin Trudeau’s tenure, the temporary foreign worker and international student programs spiralled out of control, eroding public trust.

Re-establishing that trust by bringing immigration policy back under control must be one of the federal government’s highest priorities.

The competitive disadvantage lies in the area of housing. “Canada’s housing crisis is not only a moral and generational scandal,” they say. “It is an economic blockade.” High housing costs drive out younger workers and those with diverse skills essential to growing a business, creating both a housing and a labour shortage.

Again, progressives advocate for government housing programs, while conservatives prefer cutting regulations and development charges, and letting the market match supply with demand.

The book is chock-full of recommendations for political leaders, from increasing supports for growing businesses to forcing municipal governments to permit densification. And the authors are well aware of the challenges these recommendations pose. (Corporate welfare! Ruining my neighbourhood!)

But the biggest challenge of all might be what they call the Canadian sense of “us.” The world has become a dangerous place, a place of aggressive hegemons and disintegrating alliances. The central question is whether Canadians can summon the collective will to respond. The sovereignty movement in Quebec, Western alienation, tension between immigrants and those born here, and between Indigenous people and settlers, all threaten our collective ability to act in the national interest.

But the challenges are not insurmountable. As the authors point out, “Canada has always had to be a negotiated country,” in which various regional, linguistic and cultural interests accommodate each other. And we are blessed with an extraordinarily high level of trust. An overwhelming majority of Canadians believe their fellow citizens are morally good rather than bad, according to a recent Pew Research Center survey. (Of those cited in the poll, the United States was the only country where a majority believe their fellow citizens are bad.)

Jared Diamond’s new book tackles the question: how much do leaders really matter?

“Canada’s future will be secured by proving that its model as a country can deliver: prosperity without ascriptive nationalism, openness without disorder, federalism without paralysis, resources without complacency, density without exclusion, innovation without small-country fatalism, and sovereignty without bluster,” the authors conclude.

“That is the promise of the Canadian sense of us.”

You may not agree with everything that Hausmann and Protzer recommend. But you should certainly listen to what they have to say.

John Ibbitson’s most recent book, co-written with Darrell Bricker, is Breaking Point: The New Big Shifts Putting Canada at Risk.