The San Jose Sharks spent much of the summer trying to turn the corner on their rebuild and transform the roster from a future contender into a current playoff team. One move they hoped would give them a jolt was trading for veteran defenseman Darnell Nurse. The Sharks acquired Nurse in exchange for defenseman Shakir Mukhamadullin and defensive prospect Zack Sharp, taking on his entire $9.25MM cap hit and the remaining four years on his deal. It was a pricey gamble to acquire a top-four defenseman, and unfortunately for the Sharks, it looks like an expensive disaster. Nurse has struggled in San Jose, and the team has been unable to mask the shortcomings in his game. The Sharks’ acquisition of Nurse was questionable from the start and felt like a team bringing in a player based purely on reputation and physical ability rather than tangible on-ice results, especially given how Nurse’s final few years in Edmonton played out. This was the ultimate case of buyer beware, and so far it’s safe to say the buyer likely has some remorse.
The evidence of Nurse’s struggles is unfortunately abundant, whether you use traditional stats, analytics, or the good old-fashioned eye test. Nurse has just one goal and one assist in 20 games thus far and is -5, while averaging 21:23 of ice time per game. Nurse and his main partner, Michael Kesselring, have been a very poor pairing for the Sharks this year, with a 20% Goals For Percentage, giving up 12 goals in 249 minutes at 5-on-5 while being on for just three goals (as per Natural Stat Trick). His possession numbers at even strength aren’t any better at 45.9%, and neither are his advanced stats. However, the odd thing is that Nurse still has his skating and, obviously, his size, but they aren’t translating into on-ice results.
The Kesselring pairing is particularly concerning, but Nurse hasn’t been effective regardless of who he’s been paired with. That’s what makes the acquisition concerning, but even more concerning is that Nurse is getting the third-most ice time of all Sharks skaters, behind only Macklin Celebrini and Jacob Trouba.
Many Sharks fans expected regression at some point during the four years left on his deal, but they likely hoped it would happen in year three or four of his Sharks tenure, not in month one. The good news for Sharks fans (if there is any) is that much of Nurse’s regression isn’t due to a decline in skill, but rather to how he’s using his talent. Nurse has struggled with gap control this season, failing to close on forwards in time and giving opponents too much time and space to work with. He’s also struggled in his own zone, running around and losing coverage at times, which has unfortunately led to many dangerous opportunities against.
All that said, none of this should shock the Sharks or their fans. Most of what was just highlighted has been Nurse’s experience for years. Nurse isn’t really an offensive defenseman, having topped 40 points just twice in his career. He also hasn’t driven play for about five years. But the defensive struggles have generally been limited to the playoffs in recent years, though it now appears Nurse might be a poor defender too.
The Sharks hoped a change of scenery would get Nurse back to his old ways, but much of his past success came from playing alongside Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl. For example, last season Nurse’s expected-goals rate at five-on-five without McDavid on the ice was 47.1%, and with him it soared to 57.5%. Nurse played a lot with McDavid, dating back to 2022-23, when 35.6% of his five-on-five shifts were with McDavid. Contrast that with last year, when it was just 23.8% of shifts. Now, the change to a new team and the absence of McDavid don’t necessarily mean his defensive skills should go off a cliff, but having the best player in the world on the ice with you more than 1/3 of the time is certainly the best defense you could ask for.
Nurse’s play is obviously a big concern for the Sharks, but his contract is an even bigger one. It seems unlikely the 31-year-old will magically roll back the clock and play like a 26-year-old again, and that aging curve could catch up with him quickly if nothing changes soon. With three years left on the contract after this one, it seems unlikely a team would take on that deal, and the Sharks could face a cap crunch sooner rather than later, with young players like Will Smith needing new contracts in the coming summers.
Sharks fans might not be concerned about future cap space, and on paper the Sharks have $29MM for next year with just five players to sign. But the bigger issue for San Jose could be the opportunity cost of blowing so much cap space on a below-replacement-level defenseman. If the Sharks want to take the next step, spending big money on a third-pairing defender isn’t the wisest choice, and general manager Mike Grier will need to address it if he wants to surround his talented young core with effective NHL players.
Plenty of NHL teams have hit the draft lottery several times yet failed to insulate their core. It happened in Edmonton for years before McDavid arrived; it’s happening in Chicago right now, and it could happen in San Jose if they don’t better allocate their salary-cap room to veterans.
The good news for the Sharks is that, for now, Nurse still has the tools of an NHL player, just not a great one. But he is early in his tenure in San Jose, and he may simply be adjusting to a new city, organization, and system. Time will tell.