Gun pointed toward his wife, in a state of emotional and mental breakdown, Zahid Ahmed\u2019s character battles his alternate personality for control, going as far as to say that Sameera is not the manifestation of his love, rather, \u201cyou are my illness. In fact, you were my illness.\u201d<\/p>\n
While it was a sincere attempt to raise awareness about the reality of those living with dissociative identity disorder, it was ultimately misguided. The creators of Ishq Zahe Naseeb (2019) essentially end up reiterating the same misconceptions and stereotypes about already exist: that they are a danger to others and themselves.<\/p>\n
This narrative choice, among other things, is part of a bigger problem in Pakistani television, which is that Pakistani writers, at their best, don\u2019t understand mental illness, and at their worst, conflate mental illness with morality.<\/p>\n
Zahid Ahmed in Ishq Zahe Naseeb\n <\/p>\n
The morality and the personal responsibility of those who suffer from psychological concerns is a topic that is often debated in many scientific and judicial circles, but the point of apprehension is how morality is woven into mental illness as a form of punishment in Pakistani dramas.<\/p>\n
Teaching a lesson<\/p>\n A clear message is sent when the fight between good and evil in a drama ends with the bad or immoral character succumbing to madness due to their hubris. Here, mental illness serves as a plot point, a moral lesson for the audience. The mental illness exhibited is not a component of a wider whole of the character, but rather a consequence of their own actions. In Madness & Civilisation: A History of Insanity in Age of Reason, Michel Foucalt differentiates<\/a> this ailment from mental illness, and calls it a madness that is a social construct, that is meant to serve a purpose. In our dramas, the purpose is caution.<\/p>\n<\/p>\n Those who err will be served divine justice. They might escape the law but they won\u2019t escape God, which is why Syed Jibran\u2019s character goes mad in Chup Raho<\/a> (2014) \u2014 it is divine retribution for sexually assaulting his sister-in-law played by Sajal Aly. Similarly, Riz Kamali\u2019s character in Bubbly Kya Chahti Hai starts losing her mental bearings after being divorced by her husband (played by Shahzad Raza) for her infidelity, only to then be immediately be rejected by her lover (played by Salahuddin Tunio) too. Her madness is the consequence of her own greed and duplicity. Both of these characters\u2019 lunacy is their punishment for all the wrong they\u2019ve done and the sins they committed against other people.<\/p>\n Losing faith and culture is also often shown as a downfall. The modern, westernised woman \u2014 outspoken, greedy, and ambitious \u2014 is painted as unstable compared to her quiet, modest, and religious counterpart. One is seen as \u2018bad\u2019 for being too bold, the other as \u2018good\u2019 for sticking to tradition. Weak faith equals weak identity in these stories, making the modern woman seem neurotic and fragile; someone who can\u2019t handle failure or disappointment.<\/p>\n This lesson is driven home by the suicides of Naveen Waqar and Aisha Malik\u2019s characters in Humsafar (2011) and Mann Mayal<\/a> (2016) respectively. Sara (Waqar) is shown to wear western clothes, work at an office and belong to a upper class background, in contrast to her rival (Mahira Khan), who is seen with her head covered in a dupatta, teaches tuition at home and belongs to a lower-middle class background. In the same vein, Jeena (Malik) is a woman who works at an office, has no family and hence is self-reliant, very unlike her rival (Maya Ali) who is simplistic, eastern, docile and often shown praying. After repeated failures and rejection in their pursuit of love, Sara and Jeena find no solution except taking their lives, while their rivals persevere through their hardships with patience, faith and humility.<\/p>\n By repeatedly presenting mental illness as \u2018punishment\u2019 for immorality and injustice, or a consequence of weak faith or weak mind, mental illness itself becomes synonymous with immorality, and mentally ill individuals become wicked and feeble minded.<\/p>\n Women and madness<\/p>\n Under the patriarchy, being \u201cfeeble-minded\u201d has long been linked with being a woman. For centuries, women have been stereotyped as emotional, irrational, and a bit too simple. So it\u2019s no surprise that when stories show someone \u201cgoing mad,\u201d it\u2019s usually a woman.<\/p>\n Iqra Aziz plays Nimra in Jhooti\n <\/p>\n Even psychology (a field built to understand people) has a history of labelling women\u2019s feelings and experiences as problems that need \u2018fixing\u2019.<\/p>\n Women losing their minds has been a go-to trope for ages, it has even been used by Shakespeare \u2014 think of Ophelia\u2019s fate in Hamlet. That\u2019s because madness is often seen as the opposite of masculine logic and control. And since society treats emotion and delicacy as \u201cfeminine,\u201d it\u2019s easy to link mental illness with womanhood. Women are viewed as closer to guilt, melancholia, and hysteria, which makes them easy targets for being labeled as mentally unstable. In a way, madness has become feminised: seen as something women naturally fall into just by being who they are.<\/p>\n Phyllis Chesler theorises in Women & Madness that men are typically allowed a broader range of acceptable behaviours than their female counterparts: \u201cThus, since women are allowed fewer total behaviours and are more strictly confined to their role-sphere than men are, women\u2026 will commit more behaviours that are seen as ill or unacceptable.\u201d<\/p>\n When it comes to traditional gender roles, women are expected to be soft-spoken, kind, and dependent on men. Those who deviate from these expectations are often portrayed as antagonists, characterised by traits like cunning and ambition. Such female characters engage in manipulation and deceit, leading the more naive characters to fall victim to their schemes.<\/p>\n Meanwhile, men who make mistakes don\u2019t always face the same judgment. In fact, they\u2019re often given the chance to grow, redeem themselves, or just walk away from their mistakes. Take Bashar Momin (2014), for instance, whose titular character is a money launderer, an arrogant and egoistic man prone to fits of anger who mistreats his employees and his wife alike. At the end of the show, after some self-reflection, he is a changed man, soft-spoken, respectful and loving.<\/p>\n The narrative suggests that women who violate societal norms face severe repercussions, often culminating in their madness or victimisation like Nimra in Jhooti (2020), Nisha in Jalan (2020), Gohar in Nand (2020) or Nayla in Titli (2017), while men frequently evade punishment. In 2017\u2019s Khani Feroze Khan\u2019s character may have committed murder, but he found God at the end of the show, and hence gets to be redeemed, highlighting the harsher penalties imposed by the patriarchy on women. Consequently, \u2018bad women\u2019 are portrayed as irredeemable figures, stripped of nuance and rationality, learning the weight of their transgressions solely through divine retribution.<\/p>\n A heavy crown (for the ladies)<\/p>\n The antagonists\/anti-heroes in Jhooti, Jalan, Titli and Nand are power hungry, which is impermissible in a patriarchal society. Iqra Aziz\u2019s character in Jhooti<\/a> is a greedy woman, who will use any means necessary to marry rich, whether she has to lie, cheat, steal or harass her sisters-in-law, even causing a miscarriage. Similarly, Minal Khan\u2019s character in Jalan is incessantly and obsessively jealous of her sister, whose husband she is in love with, eventually scheming her way into marrying him while her sister sets herself on fire in grief.<\/p>\n Hania Aamir as Nayla in Titli\n <\/p>\n Bewilderingly, despite having an equal part in the affair that lead to Mishu\u2019s (Areeba Habib) death, Emmad Irfani\u2019s character doesn\u2019t go mad like Nisha, and simply dies. Faiza Hasan\u2019s character in Nand (2020) ruins her brothers\u2019 married lives through her manipulative tactics, while Hania Aamir\u2019s character in Titli (2017) is vain and greedy and eventually abandons her husband and children to be with another man, culminating in her downfall.<\/p>\n The message is clear: women who seek control are seen as irrational, and their punishment is madness. Because power, in these stories, is still treated as a male trait.<\/p>\n Virtuous women are docile, while unconscionable women are ambitious, as aptly shown in Kasak (2020), in which the \u2018good\u2019 woman (Iqra Aziz), obediently accepts her marriage to man who has a young son, while the \u2018bad\u2019 woman (Ayesha Toor) is a modern working woman who is both a bad mother and wife.<\/p>\n The only time women seem to be shown using their agency is when they\u2019re trying to control other people (or their own lives) and then they\u2019re punished for it by being driven to madness. This demonises the mere thought of women\u2019s agency. The domination of men\u2019s lives by women is unacceptable, like in Balaa (2019), in which Ushna Shah\u2019s character slowly kills Taimoor\u2019s (Bilal Abbas) entire family to be the only thing he has. However, the domination of women\u2019s lives by men can be exonerated, such as in Mann Mast Malaang<\/a> (2025), in which Danish Taimoor\u2019s character ties up the female lead to keep her from leaving him, or in Ishq Hai (2021), where he kidnaps his lover and forces her into marriage.<\/p>\n The patriarchy puts women in a tight box. If a woman reaches for power, she\u2019s seen as not feminine enough and is often portrayed as going mad \u2014 like Gohar in Nand, who is controlling and overbearing, which are \u2018unfeminine\u2019 qualities. On the flip side, if she sticks to traditional femininity, she\u2019s seen as weak and ends up breaking down emotionally \u2014 Mahira Khan\u2019s character in Hum Kahan Ke Sachay Thay<\/a> (2021) who is a victim of her cousin\u2019s schemes and envy, but too innocent to know how to be taken seriously, has a slow mental breakdown; or like Samina Peerzada\u2019s character in Balaa<\/a> (2019), who goes mad with grief because of her daughters\u2019 deaths.<\/p>\n But what about men?<\/p>\n Mental illness in men is heavily stigmatised because of toxic ideas about masculinity; showing emotion is seen as weak or a loss of control. Since mental health struggles are mostly shown through women\u2019s stories, it makes these issues seem \u201cfeminine,\u201d which can make men feel ashamed or less manly for going through the same thing.<\/p>\n Faiza Hassan plays the character of Gohar in Nand\n <\/p>\n We do see women dealing with trauma \u2014 like in Chup Raho and Dar Si Jati Hai Sila (2018), whose protagonists are survivors of sexual violence \u2014 but men who also face serious trauma<\/a>, such as soldiers, victims of community violence or car crash survivors, rarely get that same attention, even though they\u2019re just as likely to suffer from PTSD. This further erases men\u2019s mental health issues.<\/p>\n The bare minimum<\/p>\n Even when dramas do attempt to portray mental illness as part of a greater whole, the representation is reductive and simplistic. Depression is only sadness and constant sobbing, anxiety is being fidgety and scared, PTSD is temporary.<\/p>\n Characters with autism are infantalised and presented as intellectually impaired \u2014like Imran Ashraf\u2019s Bhola in Ranjha Ranjha Kardi (2018), who is coded autistically and shown like a child in an adult\u2019s body \u2014 despite the fact that autism is a spectrum. Female characters are often seen fainting and immediately diagnosed with a \u201cnervous breakdown\u201d (an outdated term) after being driven to their emotional limits.<\/p>\n To top it all off, there is rarely any representation of treatment, which ties back to themes of morality; bad people get punished, and good people recover on their own \u2014\u00a0like how Bhola\u2019s intellectual impairment seems to improve on its own. With this lesson, madness is a desired outcome, a fitting punishment befalling the sinner.<\/p>\n Ushna Shah as Nigar in Balaa\n <\/p>\n When Taimoor drives Nigar mad towards the end of Balaa, the audience feels vindicated, further discouraging them from feeling compassion towards individuals with mental illness; immoral people deserve it, and moral people don\u2019t remain mentally ill, divorcing treatment entirely from the conversation.<\/p>\n Why does this matter?<\/p>\n These kinds of portrayals just add to the stigma around mental illness in our culture. Seeing the same negative images again and again makes people afraid of mental health issues and of those dealing with them.<\/p>\n A 2023 review<\/a> by James Goodwin and Laura Behan found that media stereotypes lead the public to hold biased views and keep their distance from people who use mental health services. A study<\/a> from the Czech Republic also showed that these portrayals can stop people from getting help. They lower self-esteem, make it harder to stick with treatment, and get in the way of recovery.<\/p>\n Good mental health representation shouldn\u2019t be a second thought, but the most primal part of the drama the writers set out to create. A critical media lens is essential in challenging harmful portrayals and advocating for more compassionate, realistic depictions of psychological struggles, because these portrayals have real life consequences. Pakistani television is still in the early stages of offering good representation of mental illness, for both men and women. If Pakistani creators must insist on portraying mental illness, they can at least take a page out of international media like Midsommar (2019), which explores female madness through a critical feminist lens.<\/p>\n Mental health issues aren\u2019t \u2018good\u2019 or \u2018bad\u2019 nor are they the consequences of someone\u2019s actions \u2014 they just are. Offering nuanced stories where mental illness doesn\u2019t exist solely to serve a moral narrative is the only way to dismantle the taboos of our culture.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"Gun pointed toward his wife, in a state of emotional and mental breakdown, Zahid Ahmed\u2019s character battles his…\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":1464,"comment_status":"","ping_status":"","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[60],"tags":[97,259,260],"class_list":{"0":"post-1463","1":"post","2":"type-post","3":"status-publish","4":"format-standard","5":"has-post-thumbnail","7":"category-mental-health","8":"tag-health","9":"tag-mental-health","10":"tag-mentalhealth"},"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/1463","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=1463"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/1463\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/1464"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=1463"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=1463"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=1463"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}