{"id":208947,"date":"2025-10-08T11:22:07","date_gmt":"2025-10-08T11:22:07","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/208947\/"},"modified":"2025-10-08T11:22:07","modified_gmt":"2025-10-08T11:22:07","slug":"trending-at-the-ptab-petitioners-settled-expectations-patent","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/208947\/","title":{"rendered":"Trending At The PTAB: Petitioners&#8217; Settled Expectations &#8211; Patent"},"content":{"rendered":"<p><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/1688668a.jpg\" width=\"805\" height=\"209\" alt=\"1688668a.jpg\"\/><\/p>\n<p>&#13;<br \/>\nSettled Expectations Considered for Discretionary&#13;<br \/>\nDenial: Acting Director Coke Morgan Stewart&#8217;s March 26&#13;<br \/>\nmemorandum introduced the concept of settled expectations without&#13;<br \/>\nlimiting it to patent owners or petitioners, expanding the scope of&#13;<br \/>\nconsiderations for discretionary denial of inter partes review&#13;<br \/>\npetitions.&#13;<br \/>\n&#13;<br \/>\nInitial Settled Expectations Decisions Favored Patent&#13;<br \/>\nOwners: Early decisions by the Acting Director often&#13;<br \/>\nfavored patent owners by denying institution where challenged&#13;<br \/>\npatents had been in force for six years or more.&#13;<br \/>\n&#13;<br \/>\nPetitioners Can Also Have Settled&#13;<br \/>\nExpectations: Recent PTAB decisions show a new trend in&#13;<br \/>\napplying settled expectations, recognizing that petitioners&#8217;&#13;<br \/>\narguments regarding long delays in enforcement, expired patents,&#13;<br \/>\nprior nonassertion, and successful prior PTAB outcomes can&#13;<br \/>\nsuccessfully counter discretionary denial.&#13;<\/p>\n<p>Former U.S. Patent and Trademark Office Acting Director Coke&#13;<br \/>\nMorgan Stewart&#8217;s March 26 memorandum providing interim&#13;<br \/>\nprocesses for Patent Trial and Appeal Board workload management&#13;<br \/>\nidentified several new factors that the director now considers in&#13;<br \/>\ndetermining whether to discretionarily deny inter partes review&#13;<br \/>\npetitions, including &#8220;settled expectations of the&#13;<br \/>\nparties.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Stewart, now deputy director of the USPTO, has typically applied&#13;<br \/>\nthis factor in favor of patent owners, frequently exercising&#13;<br \/>\ndiscretion to deny petitions challenging patents that have been in&#13;<br \/>\nforce for six or more years due to a patent owner&#8217;s settled&#13;<br \/>\nexpectations.<\/p>\n<p>Recent decisions, however, illustrate that petitioners are&#13;<br \/>\nhaving increased success in asserting that their own settled&#13;<br \/>\nexpectations are sufficient to avoid discretionary denial of&#13;<br \/>\ninstitution.<\/p>\n<p>Such settled expectations have come in the form of long delays&#13;<br \/>\nin a patent owner filing an infringement lawsuit, the patent owner&#13;<br \/>\nunexpectedly asserting its patent in new industries or technology&#13;<br \/>\nspaces, or when the petitioner has previously succeeded in&#13;<br \/>\nchallenging a related patent.<\/p>\n<p>This article explores these evolving changes in the PTAB&#13;<br \/>\nlandscape, including cases such as Apple Inc. v. Ferid&#13;<br \/>\nAllani; Home Depot USA Inc. v. H2 Intellect LLC;&#13;<br \/>\nDataDome SA v. Arkose Labs Holdings Inc.; and <a href=\"http:\/\/www.mondaq.com\/redirection.asp?article_id=1688668&amp;company_id=1373&amp;redirectaddress=https:\/\/links.us1.defend.egress.com\/Warning?crId=68de83633c729ef16c69fe9a&amp;Domain=finnegan.com&amp;Threat=eNpzrShJLcpLzAEADmkDRA%3D%3D&amp;Lang=en&amp;Base64Url=eNrLKCkpKLbS1y8vL9fLSSw3NjPQS87P1QfigsS8zNRi_YL84uR8AAoEDeo%3D&amp;@OriginalLink=www.law360.com\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">POSCO Co.<\/a> Ltd. v. <a href=\"http:\/\/www.mondaq.com\/redirection.asp?article_id=1688668&amp;company_id=1373&amp;redirectaddress=https:\/\/links.us1.defend.egress.com\/Warning?crId=68de83633c729ef16c69fe9a&amp;Domain=finnegan.com&amp;Threat=eNpzrShJLcpLzAEADmkDRA%3D%3D&amp;Lang=en&amp;Base64Url=eNoNw8EJACAIAMCNNAh6tI1IUKApJbh-HdyM8NsRMxOEsrYCbIq_017jIh0eYkdXBMkDh4kROQ%3D%3D&amp;@OriginalLink=www.law360.com\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">ArcelorMittal<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p>IPR Petitioners Can Have Settled Expectations&#13;<br \/>\nToo<\/p>\n<p>Stewart&#8217;s March 26 memorandum did not limit the settled&#13;<br \/>\nexpectations factor to the expectations of either patent owners or&#13;<br \/>\npetitioners. Early decisions on discretionary denial, however,&#13;<br \/>\nfrequently indicated that patent owners may be considered to have&#13;<br \/>\nsettled expectations tied to the age of the patent.<\/p>\n<p>As more decisions have issued, it has become clear petitioners&#13;<br \/>\ntoo may establish settled expectations in certain circumstances,&#13;<br \/>\nsupporting referral of their petitions for consideration by the&#13;<br \/>\nPTAB on the merits.<\/p>\n<p>Initial Settled Expectation Decisions<\/p>\n<p>In the months immediately following the March 26 memorandum,&#13;<br \/>\nStewart typically applied settled expectations in favor of patent&#13;<br \/>\nowners, particularly when patents had been in force for six years&#13;<br \/>\nor more.<\/p>\n<p>That approach aligned with prior statements from Stewart tying&#13;<br \/>\nthe doctrine to Title 35 of the U.S. Code, Section 286, which&#13;<br \/>\nimposes a six-year statute of limitations for recovering&#13;<br \/>\ninfringement damages. In Dabico Airport Solutions Inc. v. AXA&#13;<br \/>\nPower APS, decided by the PTAB on June 18, the director&#13;<br \/>\nexplained:<\/p>\n<p>Although there is no bright-line rule on when expectations&#13;<br \/>\nbecome settled, in general, the longer the patent has been in&#13;<br \/>\nforce, the more settled expectations should be. This approach&#13;<br \/>\naligns with other approaches to settled expectations and&#13;<br \/>\nincentives, for example, for filing infringement lawsuits.<\/p>\n<p>By mid-2025, the settled expectations factor operated primarily&#13;<br \/>\nas a shield against IPR institution, favoring patent owners. Recent&#13;<br \/>\ndirector decisions, however, illustrate a shift: Petitioners are&#13;<br \/>\nbeginning to leverage their own settled expectations successfully,&#13;<br \/>\nsometimes even against Fintiv considerations that could otherwise&#13;<br \/>\nsupport discretionary denial.<\/p>\n<p>Petitioners&#8217; Settled Expectations: Recognized, But&#13;<br \/>\nNot Always Enough<\/p>\n<p>The director&#8217;s recent decisions reflect a willingness to&#13;<br \/>\ncredit petitioners&#8217; reliance on settled expectations arguments,&#13;<br \/>\neven if they are not always dispositive.<\/p>\n<p>In DataDome SA v. Arkose Labs Holdings, Inc., <a href=\"http:\/\/www.mondaq.com\/redirection.asp?article_id=1688668&amp;company_id=1373&amp;redirectaddress=https:\/\/links.us1.defend.egress.com\/Warning?crId=68de83633c729ef16c69fe9a&amp;Domain=finnegan.com&amp;Threat=eNpzrShJLcpLzAEADmkDRA%3D%3D&amp;Lang=en&amp;Base64Url=eNoNyFEKhDAMBcATxexaVPA2pQ0YqK30RYKe3n4NzGF2YWd296lED-tvSu3k2E1TEfActmUNf4aJjyQFbgHl9koFna0LZUXqYtpq7A9lqRrLIClG4QOV4yOg&amp;@OriginalLink=www.law360.com\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">decided<\/a> Aug. 14, both parties invoked settled&#13;<br \/>\nexpectations.<\/p>\n<p>The patent owner emphasized that the challenged patents had been&#13;<br \/>\nin force for 17 and 10 years. The petitioner argued it had relied&#13;<br \/>\non the prior owner&#8217;s failure to assert the patents, pointing to&#13;<br \/>\nlicensing discussions a year or two earlier where the petitioner&#13;<br \/>\nstated that they did not believe they required a license to the&#13;<br \/>\nidentified patents, indicating they had apparently evaluated the&#13;<br \/>\npatents.<\/p>\n<p>The director acknowledged that a concession of noninfringement&#13;<br \/>\ncould establish petitioner expectations, but concluded that the&#13;<br \/>\npetitioner&#8217;s argument was not enough to outweigh the patent&#13;<br \/>\nowner&#8217;s expectations, based on the length of time the patents&#13;<br \/>\nhad been in force.<\/p>\n<p>The petitioners have also argued that they reasonably expected&#13;<br \/>\nnonassertion where their technology was fundamentally different&#13;<br \/>\nfrom the claimed inventions.<\/p>\n<p>In BOE Technology Group Co. v. Optronic Sciences LLC,&#13;<br \/>\n<a href=\"http:\/\/www.mondaq.com\/redirection.asp?article_id=1688668&amp;company_id=1373&amp;redirectaddress=https:\/\/links.us1.defend.egress.com\/Warning?crId=68de83633c729ef16c69fe9a&amp;Domain=finnegan.com&amp;Threat=eNpzrShJLcpLzAEADmkDRA%3D%3D&amp;Lang=en&amp;Base64Url=eNoNy2EKgCAMQOETrVlCRbcRHTUwlW0wun3C-_m-x2zohejuS00e97Dk_mIS41xJcYtHONeIPKB7I1GoSW6qHzg3mKmRzxsUGjmpQWHNQsa9QZcyxQ_GQCPs&amp;@OriginalLink=www.law360.com\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">decided<\/a> <a href=\"http:\/\/www.mondaq.com\/redirection.asp?article_id=1688668&amp;company_id=1373&amp;redirectaddress=https:\/\/links.us1.defend.egress.com\/Warning?crId=68de83633c729ef16c69fe9a&amp;Domain=finnegan.com&amp;Threat=eNpzrShJLcpLzAEADmkDRA%3D%3D&amp;Lang=en&amp;Base64Url=eNoNy2EKgCAMQOETrVlCRbcRHTUwlW0wun3C-_m-x2zohejuS00e97Dk_mIS41xJcYtHONeIPKB7I1GoSW6qHzg3mKmRzxsUGjmpQWHNQsa9QZcyxQ_GQCPs&amp;@OriginalLink=www.law360.com\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">July 29, the petitioner argued that its&#13;<br \/>\naccused products used a top-gate transistor structure, precisely&#13;<br \/>\nthe opposite of the bottom-gate structure claimed in the challenged&#13;<br \/>\npatents, such that it therefore had no reason to expect&#13;<br \/>\nassertion.<\/p>\n<p>The director credited this as weighing against discretionary&#13;<br \/>\ndenial, but ultimately concluded that the patents&#8217; 12-year age&#13;<br \/>\nand the earlier district court trial schedule created stronger&#13;<br \/>\nsettled expectations for the patent owner.<\/p>\n<p>The same line of reasoning surfaced again in Transcend&#13;<br \/>\nInformation Inc. v. Truesight Communications LLC, <a href=\"http:\/\/www.mondaq.com\/redirection.asp?article_id=1688668&amp;company_id=1373&amp;redirectaddress=https:\/\/links.us1.defend.egress.com\/Warning?crId=68de83633c729ef16c69fe9a&amp;Domain=finnegan.com&amp;Threat=eNpzrShJLcpLzAEADmkDRA%3D%3D&amp;Lang=en&amp;Base64Url=eNoNyFEKgDAIANATmdWgotuMTcpY21BJun29z3eadd0R3X0o0cMyDqndGMU4FVKcwxqmeUE18j9B6KJkChtwF-hkbNyqgp9cCNpDIpy5HnDHFzJVjuUDyNAjvw%3D%3D&amp;@OriginalLink=www.law360.com\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">decided<\/a> Aug. 4. Transcend argued it reasonably&#13;<br \/>\nexpected no infringement allegations because the patent required a&#13;<br \/>\nkiosk, which it did not make.<\/p>\n<p>The director acknowledged the argument, citing BOE, but again&#13;<br \/>\nfound that the patent&#8217;s 10-year duration and the earlier&#13;<br \/>\ndistrict court trial date overcame Petitioner&#8217;s&#13;<br \/>\nsettled-expectations argument.<\/p>\n<p>When Petitioners&#8217; Settled Expectations Prove&#13;<br \/>\nDecisive<\/p>\n<p>Other recent cases demonstrate that the petitioner&#8217;s&#13;<br \/>\nreliance on settled expectations arguments can be sufficient to&#13;<br \/>\navoid denial. These outcomes highlight circumstances in which&#13;<br \/>\npetitioners can invoke settled expectations effectively.<\/p>\n<p>One theme is delay in enforcement. In Apple Inc. v. Ferid&#13;<br \/>\nAllani, <a href=\"http:\/\/www.mondaq.com\/redirection.asp?article_id=1688668&amp;company_id=1373&amp;redirectaddress=https:\/\/links.us1.defend.egress.com\/Warning?crId=68de83633c729ef16c69fe9a&amp;Domain=finnegan.com&amp;Threat=eNpzrShJLcpLzAEADmkDRA%3D%3D&amp;Lang=en&amp;Base64Url=eNoVyFkKgDAMBcATxYgtIt4mloB1qaV5muurf8OsQLWZ2d27QzyMfZeuk6Uhp0ONhzDFOPRsUP-SIGn_nk5pu8Iol-0uCfkqv6moq4EqZKGmT1a3F7WyI-Q%3D&amp;@OriginalLink=www.law360.com\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">decided<\/a> <a href=\"http:\/\/www.mondaq.com\/redirection.asp?article_id=1688668&amp;company_id=1373&amp;redirectaddress=https:\/\/links.us1.defend.egress.com\/Warning?crId=68de83633c729ef16c69fe9a&amp;Domain=finnegan.com&amp;Threat=eNpzrShJLcpLzAEADmkDRA%3D%3D&amp;Lang=en&amp;Base64Url=eNoVyFkKgDAMBcATxYgtIt4mloB1qaV5muurf8OsQLWZ2d27QzyMfZeuk6Uhp0ONhzDFOPRsUP-SIGn_nk5pu8Iol-0uCfkqv6moq4EqZKGmT1a3F7WyI-Q%3D&amp;@OriginalLink=www.law360.com\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">Sept. 5, the patent owner first contacted the&#13;<br \/>\npetitioner about a license in 2012.<\/p>\n<p>The petitioner declined, stating that it did not need one, and&#13;<br \/>\nthe patent was not asserted until eleven years later, after it had&#13;<br \/>\nexpired. Under these facts, the director found that the petitioner&#13;<br \/>\nhad sufficient settled expectations of nonenforcement to avoid a&#13;<br \/>\ndiscretionary denial of institution.<\/p>\n<p>Another important consideration concerns industry expectations.&#13;<br \/>\nIn Home Depot USA Inc. v. H2 Intellect LLC, decided Sept.&#13;<br \/>\n4, the patent had been in force for more than 12 years.<\/p>\n<p>The petitioner argued it had no reason to anticipate assertion&#13;<br \/>\nin its industry because the patent owner had previously targeted&#13;<br \/>\nsmartphones, tablets and watches, but never hardware retail. The&#13;<br \/>\ndirector agreed, finding the petitioner&#8217;s settled expectations&#13;<br \/>\nmore persuasive than the patent owner&#8217;s and referred the&#13;<br \/>\npetition.<\/p>\n<p>Petitioners have also succeeded by invoking prior success in&#13;<br \/>\nchallenging related patents. In POSCO Co. v.&#13;<br \/>\nArcelorMittal, <a href=\"http:\/\/www.mondaq.com\/redirection.asp?article_id=1688668&amp;company_id=1373&amp;redirectaddress=https:\/\/links.us1.defend.egress.com\/Warning?crId=68de83633c729ef16c69fe9a&amp;Domain=finnegan.com&amp;Threat=eNpzrShJLcpLzAEADmkDRA%3D%3D&amp;Lang=en&amp;Base64Url=eNoNyWEKgCAMQOETzUWWRLcZOmpgFm40un3-evC-0-zRHdHdQyWPaQr5vpC6Sa6sOMe0rdOCnV9hl3aAGvtgUKhkrAZFNHc2uRv1Dwo3oTqSRcfSH5LhI48%3D&amp;@OriginalLink=www.law360.com\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">decided<\/a> June 25, an ongoing U.S. International&#13;<br \/>\nTrade Commission investigation suggested denial.<\/p>\n<p>The ITC trial was set to conclude about nine months before the&#13;<br \/>\nPTAB&#8217;s projected final written decision date, suggesting that&#13;<br \/>\nthe board&#8217;s decision would not be issued until after the&#13;<br \/>\nconclusion of the ITC investigation.<\/p>\n<p>However, the petitioner pointed to its earlier success in&#13;<br \/>\ninvalidating all claims of a parent patent in a previous case&#13;<br \/>\n\u2014 also POSCO Co. v. ArcelorMittal \u2014 decided Jan. 5,&#13;<br \/>\n2021. The director concluded that it was reasonable for the&#13;<br \/>\npetitioner to expect the related claims to be vulnerable, and&#13;<br \/>\ninstitution was referred despite the parallel proceeding.<\/p>\n<p>Finally, reliance may be persuasive where a patent has already&#13;<br \/>\nexpired or lapsed. In Globus Medical Inc. v. Spinelogik&#13;<br \/>\nInc., <a href=\"http:\/\/www.mondaq.com\/redirection.asp?article_id=1688668&amp;company_id=1373&amp;redirectaddress=https:\/\/links.us1.defend.egress.com\/Warning?crId=68de83633c729ef16c69fe9a&amp;Domain=finnegan.com&amp;Threat=eNpzrShJLcpLzAEADmkDRA%3D%3D&amp;Lang=en&amp;Base64Url=eNoNyFEKgDAIANATmbEoqNvIZiRYxhSk27evB--KeP1AzMxJKZdtnqrdSD2kKjuWZS37XtCDcyR0ViZnh1PNGtgJTbx2DrGH-geNHyEdVPFR_gNqFSMA&amp;@OriginalLink=www.law360.com\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">decided<\/a> <a href=\"http:\/\/www.mondaq.com\/redirection.asp?article_id=1688668&amp;company_id=1373&amp;redirectaddress=https:\/\/links.us1.defend.egress.com\/Warning?crId=68de83633c729ef16c69fe9a&amp;Domain=finnegan.com&amp;Threat=eNpzrShJLcpLzAEADmkDRA%3D%3D&amp;Lang=en&amp;Base64Url=eNoNyFEKgDAIANATmbEoqNvIZiRYxhSk27evB--KeP1AzMxJKZdtnqrdSD2kKjuWZS37XtCDcyR0ViZnh1PNGtgJTbx2DrGH-geNHyEdVPFR_gNqFSMA&amp;@OriginalLink=www.law360.com\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">June 12, the patents had been in force for&#13;<br \/>\neight years but expired four years earlier due to nonpayment of&#13;<br \/>\nmaintenance fees. The director concluded that the petitioner&#13;<br \/>\nreasonably expected nonenforcement and referred the petition,&#13;<br \/>\nnotwithstanding the patent owner&#8217;s arguments to the&#13;<br \/>\ncontrary.<\/p>\n<p>Key Lessons for Practitioners<\/p>\n<p>Taken together, these cases illustrate an evolution in how the&#13;<br \/>\nsettled expectations factor is applied.<\/p>\n<p>As the director&#8217;s decisions show, petitioners that can&#13;<br \/>\ndemonstrate reliance on license negotiation history, delays in&#13;<br \/>\nenforcement, industry norms, prior PTAB outcomes or expired rights&#13;<br \/>\nmay avoid denial even when other factors might tend to support&#13;<br \/>\ndenying institution.<\/p>\n<p>No longer the exclusive domain of patent owners, the March 26&#13;<br \/>\nmemorandum&#8217;s settled expectations factor now provides&#13;<br \/>\npetitioners with multiple viable pathways to argue reliance on&#13;<br \/>\ntheir own settled expectations to avoid discretionary denial and&#13;<br \/>\nhave their petitions referred to a PTAB panel for consideration on&#13;<br \/>\nthe merits.<\/p>\n<p>The content of this article is intended to provide a general&#13;<br \/>\nguide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought&#13;<br \/>\nabout your specific circumstances.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"&#13; Settled Expectations Considered for Discretionary&#13; Denial: Acting Director Coke Morgan Stewart&#8217;s March 26&#13; memorandum introduced the concept&hellip;\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":59608,"comment_status":"","ping_status":"","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[18],"tags":[23,3,21,19,22,20,25,24],"class_list":["post-208947","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","category-united-states","tag-america","tag-news","tag-united-states","tag-united-states-of-america","tag-unitedstates","tag-unitedstatesofamerica","tag-us","tag-usa"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/208947","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=208947"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/208947\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/59608"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=208947"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=208947"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=208947"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}