{"id":209116,"date":"2025-10-08T13:01:11","date_gmt":"2025-10-08T13:01:11","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/209116\/"},"modified":"2025-10-08T13:01:11","modified_gmt":"2025-10-08T13:01:11","slug":"what-trump-means-for-john-robertss-legacy","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/209116\/","title":{"rendered":"What Trump Means for John Roberts&#8217;s Legacy"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>John G. Roberts Jr. \u201976, J.D. \u201979, has written hundreds of Supreme Court opinions in his 20 years as chief justice of the United States. The most important, to the nation and to his legacy, may be his opinion in <a href=\"https:\/\/www.supremecourt.gov\/opinions\/23pdf\/603us1r57_6k47.pdf\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">Trump v. United States<\/a>, which changed the balance of power among the branches of government\u2014and rewrote the meaning of the Constitution.<\/p>\n<p>A federal grand jury had indicted former President Donald Trump for his actions after the November 2020 election, charging him with, among other lawbreaking, using \u201cdishonesty, fraud, and deceit\u201d to prevent the peaceful transfer of power. Trump moved to dismiss the charges, arguing that he should have absolute immunity from criminal prosecution for actions he had performed while carrying out his official duties.<\/p>\n<p>In July 2024, by a 6-3 vote, the Supreme Court overruled federal trial and appeals courts to decide in Trump\u2019s favor. The Roberts opinion broadly expanded the authority of the presidency by saying that a former president is immune from prosecution, even after his tenure, for official acts he took under his exclusive authority as president. And he is likely immune, the Court ruled, for all other official acts he took while in office\u2014as the opinion put it, even in \u201cthe outer perimeter\u201d of his responsibilities. The opinion\u2019s foundational idea is that \u201cunlike anyone else, the president is a branch of government, and the Constitution vests in him sweeping powers and duties.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Over 41 pages, Roberts made his reasoning clear: the \u201cpall of potential prosecution\u201d poses a danger to the presidency and the nation if it prompts a president to hesitate to execute his duties \u201cfearlessly and fairly.\u201d Roberts emphasized that he was separating Trump\u2019s actions from the privileges of the office. \u201cWe must not confuse \u2018the issue of a power\u2019s validity with the cause it is invoked to promote,\u2019\u201d he wrote, \u201cbut must instead focus on the \u2018enduring consequences upon the balanced power structure of our Republic.\u2019\u201d<\/p>\n<p>The decision was about the prerogatives of the presidency, rather than an absolution of Trump\u2019s conduct during his first term as president or an endorsement of his cause. But it was the fullest expression the Court has ever made of a maximalist view of that power, narrowly checked by the Court and Congress.<\/p>\n<p>Its legal consequences are extreme. The Constitution sets out a deliberate order in its articles establishing the branches of power: I for Congress, II for the executive. The Court\u2019s ruling all but reverses the importance of those branches and retracts a critical power of the judiciary that limited wrongdoing by a president.<\/p>\n<p class=\"callout\">Roberts, often described as an institutionalist, has enabled the most hostile anti-institutionalist ever elected president.<\/p>\n<p>In her dissent in the case, Justice Sonia Sotomayor, joined by Justices Elena Kagan, J.D. \u201986, and Ketanji Brown Jackson \u201992, J.D. \u201996, warned about the consequences of such a broad expansion of presidential power. \u201cThe Court effectively creates a law-free zone around the President,\u201d upsetting the status quo that had existed since the nation\u2019s founding and giving blanket permission for wrongdoing, Sotomayor wrote. \u201cLet the President violate the law, let him exploit the trappings of his office for personal gain, let him use his official power for evil ends,\u201d she summarized. \u201cIn every use of official power, the President is now a king above the law.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Roberts remarked in his opinion that the \u201ctone of chilling doom\u201d in her dissent was \u201cwholly disproportionate\u201d to what the ruling meant. But Sotomayor\u2019s words proved prescient: the breadth of power that President Trump and his administration have asserted in the months since he was sworn in for his second term has made plain how boundlessly they interpret the reach of the presidency.<\/p>\n<p><img decoding=\"async\" alt=\"Justice Roberts at a podium giving a speech at the Henry J. Friendly Medal ceremony\" data-entity-type=\"file\" data-entity-uuid=\"7386bc5f-2a5e-4257-a0a2-38c8e4805b50\" height=\"1333\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/hm_10.6.25_roberts-henry-j-friendly-medal-1.webp.webp\" width=\"2000\" loading=\"lazy\"\/><br \/>\nIn 2023, Roberts received the Henry J. Friendly Medal, named after the federal judge for whom he clerked in 1979-1980. | Photograph by Sarah L. Voisin\/The Washington Post \u00a0via Getty Images<\/p>\n<p>As the legal scholar Peter Shane \u201974 <a href=\"https:\/\/www.theatlantic.com\/ideas\/archive\/2025\/07\/supreme-court-roberts-trump-dictator\/683576\/\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">wrote<\/a> in The Atlantic in July, Roberts\u2019s opinion didn\u2019t anticipate Trump acting in any of those ways\u2014even though Trump, running again for the presidency at the time of the ruling, was making promises to his supporters of precisely what he would do with barely limited power. But Shane\u2019s criticism was also much graver. \u201cNo one on the Supreme Court has gone further to enable Trump\u2019s extreme exercise of presidential power than the chief justice of the United States, John Roberts,\u201d he declared. \u201cWhat America is witnessing is a remaking of the American presidency into something closer to a dictatorship.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>He went on: \u201cTrump\u2019s use of executive power is not a distortion of the Roberts Court\u2019s theory of the presidency; it is the Court\u2019s theory of the presidency, come to life.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>The Trump opinion underscores the sometimes-contradictory nature of Roberts\u2019s record as chief. At 70, he is an exceptionally capable and strong-willed justice who takes pride in the independence of his judgment and in his tie to the eminent, nonpartisan tradition of seeking \u201cthe right result for the right reasons.\u201d Yet he is also the product of a long-building, now-dominant conservative legal movement whose triumphs are widespread, with effects that are still unfolding.<\/p>\n<p>In some corners of public opinion and judicial analysis, the Trump ruling cemented Roberts\u2019s reputation as a Republican and conservative partisan. It also cemented a view of the Court as a tool for carrying out Trump\u2019s anti-democracy agenda\u2014the opposite of what Roberts sought in his opinion.<\/p>\n<p>Now, the Trump ruling looms over cases that are likely to, or scheduled to, come before the Court in coming months, including at least two involving the government\u2019s attempts to punish Harvard for perceived political excesses\u2014which Harvard argues are a direct violation of its First Amendment rights. Other cases seem similarly fateful, about the authority of Congress, the independence of federal agencies, the use of the military in policing civilian life, and the nature of American citizenship.<\/p>\n<p>Their outcomes, along with the Court\u2019s actions in the last few years, carry the seeds of American tragedy. Roberts, often described as an institutionalist, has enabled the most hostile anti-institutionalist ever elected president. The leader of the nation\u2019s judicial system has empowered the president who is the most disdainful in history of the decrees of judges, the provisos of the Constitution, and the workings of American democracy. The chief justice, attempting to thread the needle between principle and practicality, has opened the door to the possibility of the ultimate constitutional crisis: a president\u2019s outright defiance of the Supreme Court.<\/p>\n<p class=\"text-align-center\">* * *<\/p>\n<p>In 2023, a year before the Court issued the Trump decision, Roberts received the Henry J. Friendly Medal, a prestigious award honoring his achievement in law, from a research organization of the bar\u2019s elite called the American Law Institute. The award is named for Judge Henry Friendly, A.B. 1923, LL.B. \u201927, LL.D. \u201971, who served on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit for 27 years and is considered one of America\u2019s great twentieth-century judges.<\/p>\n<p>Roberts was a Friendly law clerk for a year starting in 1979, when Roberts was 24 and Friendly was 75. He was a favorite of Friendly\u2019s among his many clerks over the years, and the feeling was mutual. Accepting the award, Roberts explained how important the judge remained as a model for him in many ways\u2014even disclosing that the robe Friendly wore on the Second Circuit hangs in his closet in the Supreme Court robing room. As Friendly did, Roberts writes his judicial opinions by hand.<\/p>\n<p class=\"callout\">\u201cI saw, on a day-to-day basis, an eye-to-eye basis, that a good and full life could be led in the law.\u201d\u00a0<br \/>\u2014 John Roberts at the Friendly Medal award ceremony in 2023<\/p>\n<p>Roberts recounted that, when he finished Harvard Law School, he questioned his choice of career, concerned that \u201cthe law was a rather cynical profession.\u201d But, he went on, \u201ca year with Henry Friendly changed everything. I saw, on a day-to-day basis, an eye-to-eye basis, that a good and full life could be led in the law.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Roberts cited \u201cthree significant aspects\u201d of Friendly\u2019s approach to judging as the touchstones of his own. The first is an open mind, not beholden to any school of legal thought (\u201cHe delighted in fitting a particular case in the context of the law as a whole\u201d). The second is a belief in the power of reason, with the steps of legal logic laid out (\u201cThere\u2019s no hiding the ball\u201d). The third is a pragmatic concern about human, social, and legal consequences. That was how the chief justice saw his own work. That was how he wanted it to be seen. That was also how some of his colleagues on the Court hoped he would craft his opinions.<\/p>\n<p>At the Friendly Medal award ceremony, Justice Kagan, who served as dean of Harvard Law School from 2003 to 2009, introduced the chief justice before he spoke. While noting, and joking, that their votes in many cases <a href=\"https:\/\/www.harvardmagazine.com\/2022\/10\/feature-justice-elena-kagan\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">have been for clashing sides<\/a>, she validated Roberts\u2019s dedication to the law and his good faith in carrying out his duties on the Court. An acclaimed writer herself, she called his prose \u201cthe best writing in law.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Roberts\u2019s opinions, Kagan said, are transparent about their reasoning and clear enough to be a useful guide for future conduct. And, pointedly, she noted that his opinions \u201cencourage, even if they don\u2019t guarantee, law that in its substance is careful and restrained and principled\u201d\u2014respectful, she implied, of precedent and of laws passed by elected bodies such as Congress; reluctant to reject settled rules and norms; and moderate as a matter of conviction, because that contributes to law\u2019s stability and to maintaining the people\u2019s trust.<\/p>\n<p>She seemed to be working the ref\u2014encouraging Roberts to follow the model of the moderate, legal process-oriented Friendly rather than the very conservative, states\u2019 rights-oriented, sometimes anti-civil-rights William Rehnquist, for whom Roberts went on to clerk at the Supreme Court.<\/p>\n<p>Roberts\u2019s record shows the influence of both philosophies\u2014as well as tenacity and intense ambition. From his youth, Roberts stood out as an achiever, a teenage National Merit Scholar and the first person from his private, Catholic Indiana high school to attend Harvard. He graduated summa cum laude and Phi Beta Kappa from Harvard College in three years. An essay he wrote about the lawyer, senator, and orator Daniel Webster, called \u201cThe Utopian Conservative,\u201d won a Bowdoin Prize for literary merit.<\/p>\n<p>Roberts was the managing editor of the Harvard Law Review, chosen by its liberal president for his talent, diligence, and integrity. He graduated magna cum laude from Harvard Law School. In The Chief, her 2019 biography of Roberts, the legal journalist Joan Biskupic describes him as an introvert who worked himself to exhaustion through college and law school and learned how to present himself with charm and humility, grace and polish.<\/p>\n<p>After excelling for Friendly, Roberts did a stellar job at the Supreme Court for then-Justice, later Chief Justice Rehnquist\u2014who was known in that period as the Lone Ranger because he sometimes wrote hardline conservative dissents that no other justice joined. Then, when President Ronald Reagan gave his inaugural address in January 1981\u2014declaring that \u201cit is time for us to realize that we\u2019re too great a nation to limit ourselves to small dreams\u201d\u2014Roberts heard a \u201ccall to action\u201d (his words), Biskupic reported, \u201cto join the ideological battle\u201d (hers).<\/p>\n<p>At 26, Roberts became a special assistant to the attorney general in the Reagan administration\u2014and soon became known in the Department of Justice as one of the New Right\u2019s steeliest and most combative and effective members. He was recruited to the White House counsel\u2019s office where, for four years, he carried out the movement\u2019s work targeting the liberalism of the Supreme Court, and especially its decisions fulfilling the purposes of the post-Civil War constitutional amendments.<\/p>\n<p><img decoding=\"async\" alt=\"Justice Roberts getting sworn in \" data-entity-type=\"file\" data-entity-uuid=\"167707a8-93e6-4087-8e23-636c2983ca36\" height=\"667\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/hm_10.6.25_justice-roberts-sworn-in.webp.webp\" width=\"1000\" loading=\"lazy\"\/><br \/>\nRoberts was sworn in as the 17th chief justice of the United States on September 29, 2005.<br \/>| Photograph related to the George W. Bush administration as part of the records of the White House photo office collection<\/p>\n<p>Where liberals on the Court saw a drive to include all people, especially of color, in the full sweep of American opportunity and the law\u2019s protection\u2014by upholding civil rights laws and improving fairness in law enforcement and other legal areas\u2014conservatives saw judicial activism that strayed from the Constitution\u2019s original intent. In 1985, in a speech at the American Enterprise Institute, Reagan\u2019s second attorney general, Edwin Meese III, decried an \u201caggressively secular liberalism often driven by an expansively egalitarian impulse.\u201d He went on, \u201cThe result has been nothing less than an abandonment of many of the traditional political and social values the great majority of Americans embrace.\u201d\u00a0<br \/>\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>A Conservative Legacy<\/p>\n<p>Each of Chief Justice Roberts\u2019s landmark conservative opinions has been countered by a liberal dissent, resting on a competing under- standing of the Constitution. In the cases highlighted throughout this article, the dissenting justice took the rare step of reading a summary from the bench when the decision was announced.<\/p>\n<p>Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, 2024<\/p>\n<p>Result: The Court overturned a foundational 40-year-old precedent known as the Chevron deference doctrine, to rule that judges may no longer defer to a government agency\u2019s interpretation of an ambiguous statute.<\/p>\n<p>Roberts, for the majority: The Chevron deference doctrine had \u201cbecome an impediment, rather than an aid, to accomplishing the basic judicial task of \u2018say[ing] what the law is.\u2019\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Justice Elena Kagan, dissenting: \u201cToday, the Court flips the script: It is now \u2018the courts (rather than the agency)\u2019 that will wield power when Congress has left an area of interpretive discretion. A rule of judicial humility gives way to a rule of judicial hubris.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>The movement sought to create a new conservative regime in law: elevating the power of the Republican presidency; reducing deference to laws made by the Democrat-dominated Congress; and packing the federal courts with conservative judges who would reach conservative results. The most prized combatants were lawyers with superb credentials, like Roberts, whose lawyerly personalities helped them thrive and succeed in the politics of the movement and more widely.<\/p>\n<p>In 1986, Roberts went to work for the Washington, D.C., law firm of Hogan &amp; Hartson (now Hogan Lovells) and was named a partner after a year. In 1992, when Roberts was 37, President George H.W. Bush nominated him to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, but the Democratic majority in the Senate blocked his confirmation vote. President George W. Bush nominated him a second time to the D.C. Circuit: he joined that court in 2003. Two years later, to Roberts\u2019s surprise, the president nominated him to replace Justice Sandra Day O\u2019Connor.<\/p>\n<p>Roberts had expected a woman would be nominated to replace the first woman ever to serve on the Supreme Court, so he felt relaxed during his interview with Bush\u2014which might explain a surprising observation of the president about a man known for being, among other things, steely and combative. In his memoir, Bush wrote: \u201cBehind the sparkling resume was a genuine man with a gentle soul.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Chief Justice Rehnquist died six and a half weeks after Bush nominated Roberts for the O\u2019Connor seat. Two days after Rehnquist\u2019s death, the president nominated him to be chief. (Bush chose Samuel A. Alito Jr. to fill O\u2019Connor\u2019s seat.)<\/p>\n<p>\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College, 2023<\/p>\n<p>Paired with a case involving the University of North Carolina, this case ended affirmative action in higher education admissions\u2014establishing a principle of colorblindness Roberts had advocated for since he was a young lawyer in the Reagan administration.<\/p>\n<p>Roberts, for the majority: \u201cThe \u2018core purpose of the Equal Protection Clause\u2019\u201d of the Constitution\u2019s Fourteenth Amendment is \u201cdo[ing] away with all governmentally imposed discrimination based on race.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Justice Sonia Sotomayor, dissenting: \u201cThe Court subverts the constitutional guarantee of equal protection by further entrenching racial inequality in education, the very foundation of our democratic government and pluralistic society.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Roberts was confirmed by the Senate 78-22. He was 50 years old: the youngest chief justice since his hero and role model of two centuries before, John Marshall. In his confirmation hearings, the most memorable speech came from Illinois Senator Barack Obama, J.D. \u201991, a former president of the Harvard Law Review, three years before he was elected president of the United States. It expressed standard partisan opposition to a judicial nominee\u2014Supreme Court confirmation votes after that largely split along party lines\u2014but it also contained a more cutting legal and political critique.<\/p>\n<p>\u201cThere is absolutely no doubt in my mind Judge Roberts is qualified to sit on the highest court in the land,\u201d Obama made clear. \u201cThe problem I had is that when I examined Judge Roberts\u2019s record and history of public service, it is my personal estimation that he has far more often used his formidable skills on behalf of the strong in opposition to the weak.\u201d He concluded, \u201cThe bottom line is this: I will be voting against John Roberts\u2019s nomination. I do so with considerable reticence. I hope that I am wrong.\u201d<\/p>\n<p class=\"text-align-center\">* * *<\/p>\n<p>The journalist Matthew Continetti, writing in The Weekly Standard in 2005, noted about Roberts\u2019s prize-winning essay on Daniel Webster that, as a college student, Roberts was drawn to Webster\u2019s \u201cability to engage in politics while behaving as if he were above politics.\u201d As chief, Roberts has done something strikingly similar. The centerpiece of his Senate confirmation testimony was about his view that the work of the Court is not political:<\/p>\n<p class=\"indent\">Judges are not politicians who can promise to do certain things in exchange for votes\u2026I will decide every case based on the record, according to the rule of law, without fear or favor, to the best of my ability, and I will remember that it\u2019s my job to call balls and strikes, and not to pitch or bat.<\/p>\n<p>But as the legal scholar Neil Siegel told me, \u201cWhether it\u2019s John Marshall or John Roberts, when justices say, \u2018We do law, not politics,\u2019 they are acting politically, not legally.\u201d In an article scheduled to come out next spring in the Harvard Law Review, Siegel and the legal scholar Curtis Bradley, J.D. \u201988, call that type of move \u201cjudicial self-protection.\u201d They say that Supreme Court justices have engaged in it to maintain influence in the political world when they have faced political threats from the executive, the states, or Congress. The Court must persuade powerful politicians to abide by its decisions and, in the case of the president, enforce them. \u201cIn short,\u201d they write, \u201cthe Court has two central tasks, especially when it is under threat: preserving the Constitution and the rule of law; and protecting itself.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Roberts has angered conservatives and surprised liberals with occasional opinions and votes that were forms of judicial self-protection. The best-known came in 2012, with the Court\u2019s long-anticipated ruling on the Affordable Care Act, a prime achievement of the Obama administration that had narrowly passed Congress with no Republican support. Roberts voted with four liberals on the Court to uphold the law, on the grounds that its \u201cindividual mandate,\u201d compelling people to purchase health insurance, could be characterized as a tax. But he also joined the Court\u2019s four other conservative justices in striking down the use of the Commerce Clause to justify such mandates\u2014an outcome liberals condemned as a needless curtailment of congressional authority.<\/p>\n<p><img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/hm_10.6.25_affordable-care-act-supreme-court-protest-2012.webp.webp\" data-entity-uuid=\"f2ab49ff-17e9-45bb-a2b9-1a1a468dd146\" data-entity-type=\"file\" alt=\"Person holding sign reading &quot;Obamacare declares war on religion&quot; outside Supreme Court.\" width=\"2000\" height=\"1293\" loading=\"lazy\"\/><\/p>\n<p><img decoding=\"async\" alt=\"Pro-life demonstrators with megaphones outside Supreme Court.\" data-entity-type=\"file\" data-entity-uuid=\"b55b2f87-b88d-4e74-b834-fbb92fa612d6\" height=\"1333\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/hm_10.6.25_anti-abortion-protestors-supreme-court-2024.webp.webp\" width=\"2000\" loading=\"lazy\"\/><br \/>\nAbove: A sign-holder is among the marchers who gathered to protest the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act in front of the U.S. Supreme Court on March 26, 2012, in Washington, D.C. Below: Anti-abortion protestors are met by counter-protestors in front of the Supreme Court on June 21, 2024, as citizens await a ruling on high-profile abortion rights cases. | From top: photographs by Andrew Harnik\/Getty Images and Mark Wilson\/Getty Images<\/p>\n<p>Linda Greenhouse \u201968, who won a Pulitzer Prize for her New York Times reporting on the Court, wrote then that she couldn\u2019t \u201cremember a time when [followers of the Court were] so fixated on a single justice\u2019s single vote\u201d\u2014or described it with such contradictory narratives. From the right, she wrote, Roberts was blasted as \u201ca traitorous turncoat and a weakling to boot, unable to withstand liberal \u2018bullying\u2019\u201d; from the left, as \u201ca cynical manipulator who \u2018wanted to maintain the Supreme Court as a playpen for anti-government sophistry.\u2019\u201d<\/p>\n<p>But others praised Roberts\u2019s courage for embodying the \u201cvirtue of compromise\u201d through a Solomonic approach that he has used in other prominent cases, such as the Court\u2019s historic 2022 ruling in Dobbs v. Jackson Women\u2019s Health Organization, which ended the nationwide right to abortion. In that case, Roberts joined the Court\u2019s five other conservatives in upholding a Mississippi statute that banned most abortions after 15 weeks of pregnancy, yet he did not vote with them to overturn the right. His divided vote separated him from the unprecedented decision of the other conservatives\u2014and from the extraordinary, jointly signed dissent of the liberal justices\u2014in a move of judicial self-protection that did nothing to protect the Court from a cascade of criticism.<\/p>\n<p>Roberts\u2019s efforts at judicial self-protection\u2014usually called institutionalism\u2014have often simply delayed conservative outcomes and haven\u2019t altered the overall picture of his time as chief. From his arrival on the Court until now, his leadership, votes, and opinions have mainly helped move the law and the nation far to the right. In an <a href=\"https:\/\/static1.squarespace.com\/static\/60188505fb790b33c3d33a61\/t\/62bdf6c3fe1d73388071af20\/1656616644476\/2021TermDataReport.pdf\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">analysis<\/a> prepared for The New York Times and available in the Supreme Court Database, the political scientists Lee Epstein, Andrew Martin, and Kevin Quinn found that in major cases, the Roberts Court\u2019s record is the most conservative of any Supreme Court in roughly a century.<\/p>\n<p>A year after the abortion ruling, Greenhouse wrote: \u201cTo appreciate that transformation\u2019s full dimension, consider the robust conservative wish list that greeted the new chief justice 18 years ago. Overturn Roe v. Wade. Reinterpret the Second Amendment to make private gun ownership a constitutional right. Eliminate race-based affirmative action in university admissions. Elevate the place of religion across the legal landscape. Curb the regulatory power of federal agencies.\u201d She underscored that \u201cevery goal on the conservative wish list had been achieved. All of it. To miss that remarkable fact is to miss the story of the Roberts court.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><img decoding=\"async\" alt=\"Nine Supreme Court justices posing in front of red curtain.\" data-entity-type=\"file\" data-entity-uuid=\"30d8d221-a708-4876-81f1-7edeffededd0\" height=\"1333\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/hm_10.6.25_roberts-supreme-court-portrait.webp.webp\" width=\"2000\" loading=\"lazy\"\/><br \/>\nFront row (left to right): Associate Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Clarence Thomas, Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr., Associate Justices Samuel A. Alito Jr. and Elena Kagan. Back row: Associate Justices Amy Coney Barrett, Neil M. Gorsuch, Brett M. Kavanaugh, and Ketanji Brown Jackson. | Collection of the Supreme Court of the United States\/in the public domain<\/p>\n<p class=\"text-align-center\">* * *<\/p>\n<p>Ten months into his tenure as chief justice, Roberts had expressed his concern about the consequences of a Court seen as doing politics, not law, in a 2006 Atlantic <a href=\"https:\/\/www.theatlantic.com\/magazine\/archive\/2007\/01\/robertss-rules\/305559\/\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">interview<\/a> with Jeffrey Rosen \u201982, a George Washington University law professor and the president and CEO of the National Constitution Center. (The chief justice declined to comment for Harvard Magazine about that interview or about his tenure on the Court.)<\/p>\n<p>Roberts spoke about the Supreme Court\u2019s \u201ccredibility and legitimacy as an institution\u201d and gave a straightforward definition of legitimacy: when people see the justices as Republicans and Democrats, they view the Court as political and polarized and they don\u2019t respect or trust it. The chief justice said he was especially concerned about \u201cthe personalization of judicial politics\u201d on the Court through the proliferation of concurring and dissenting opinions. \u201cInstead of nine justices moving in nine separate directions,\u201d Roberts told Rosen, \u201cit would be good to have a commitment on the part of the Court to act as a Court, rather than being more concerned about the consistency and coherency of an individual judicial record.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>In the years Roberts has been chief, he has continued to present himself much as he did in that interview, though legal conservatism has changed in ways that don\u2019t always align with views he has expressed in Court opinions and at public events. The legal scholar David Strauss \u201973, J.D. \u201978, commented to me, \u201cHe thinks, \u2018Look, we built up these institutions over the centuries, including the Supreme Court, and there\u2019s a lot in them that\u2019s really worth protecting.\u2019\u201d But, Strauss went on, \u201cUnlike conservatives of previous generations, today\u2019s conservatives are uninterested in, and even dismissive of, judicial precedents and traditional ideas about the roles of courts and the executive branch.\u201d<\/p>\n<p class=\"callout\">Opinion polls show that the public views the Court as partisan\u2014and approves of it, as an institution, far less than in the past.<\/p>\n<p>That could be part of the reason other justices have not always heeded Roberts\u2019s desire for coherency. In decisions on the merits handed down by this summer in the most recent term, the justices voted unanimously in only 42 percent of the cases. In other cases, the extent of ideological and partisan differences was often sharp and extreme.<\/p>\n<p>Opinion polls show that the public views the Court as partisan\u2014and approves of it, as an institution, far less than in the past. Defenders of the Roberts Court emphasize that the judiciary is the most admired of the three branches, but while opinion about Congress has bounced up and down over the past half-century and opinion about the presidency has risen, then fallen, in that period, opinion about the Court has almost steadily descended.<\/p>\n<p>Recent polls are especially eye-catching. In July 2025, a Gallup poll found that, for the first time in the past quarter-century, fewer than 40 percent of Americans overall approved of the Supreme Court\u2019s performance: 11 percent of Democrats, compared to 75 percent of Republicans.<\/p>\n<p>In June 2024, the National Opinion Research Center at the University of Chicago reported that most of the public lacks confidence in the Court\u2019s rulings on abortion, voting and election rights, gun policy, and especially presidential power and immunity\u2014hallmarks of the Roberts Court. In that poll, only 16 percent of Americans reported \u201ca great deal of confidence\u201d in the Court\u201429 percent of Republicans, 10 percent of Independents, and 7 percent of Democrats. Overall, 40 percent of Americans had \u201chardly any confidence at all.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Most striking, considering Roberts\u2019s desire to be a consensus-builder, is the way the public sees the individual justices as avatars of ideology. Seventy percent of Americans in that 2024 poll said justices are \u201cmore likely to try to shape the law to fit their own ideologies\u201d\u201450 percent of Republicans, 74 percent of Independents, and 84 percent of Democrats. The numbers reflect the public grasp of the ambition of the Court\u2019s conservative super-majority. As the legal historian Robert Post \u201969, Ph.D. \u201980, wrote, \u201cThe contemporary Court plainly and publicly aspires to reshape the landscape of American constitutional law.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Regardless of the reasoning Roberts laid out in his opinion in Trump v. United States, the public was likely to view it through a partisan lens. That\u2019s been even more true after the first eight months of the second Trump administration.<\/p>\n<p>Relying on the Roberts Court\u2019s broad interpretation of presidential power, Trump and his appointees have transformed the Justice Department into a protector of the president\u2019s interests. They have used it to investigate, prosecute, and otherwise pressure individuals and institutions that have challenged Trump or his administration, in what is meant to be\u2014and is widely seen as\u2014a campaign of retribution.<\/p>\n<p>In widespread roundups, they have used U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement against immigrants whom, without proof, they have deemed enemies of America. They have attempted to return immigrant children to dangerous home countries without due process, in the shadow of night, in efforts to circumvent federal courts. They have turned the FBI and the military into aggressive police forces based on declarations of public safety emergencies that lower courts have ruled don\u2019t exist.<\/p>\n<p>They have disparaged federal courts and defied a multitude of federal court rulings. The Washington Post reported in July that of 337 lawsuits filed by that date against the current Trump administration, federal judges ruled against the government 165 times, and \u201cthe administration is accused of defying or frustrating court oversight in 57 of those cases\u2014almost 35 percent\u2014\u201cunprecedented for any presidential administration.\u201d (A whistleblower last spring <a href=\"https:\/\/www.documentcloud.org\/documents\/25982172-doj-whistleblower-letter\/\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">charged<\/a> that, in one high-profile deportation case, leaders in Trump\u2019s Justice Department advised attorneys that they might need to ignore court orders or mislead judges to achieve their aims\u2014\u201ctelling the courts f*** you,\u201d as one official allegedly said.)<\/p>\n<p>\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Shelby County v. Holder, 2013<\/p>\n<p>Result: The Court diluted the Voting Rights Act of 1965 by striking down \u201cpreclearance\u201d: the law\u2019s requirement that states or parts of them with egregious histories of discrimination against minority voters had to prove that any proposed changes in election laws were not discriminatory before they took effect.<\/p>\n<p>Roberts, for the majority: \u201cThe question is whether the Act\u2019s extraordinary measures, including its disparate treatment of the States, continue to satisfy constitutional requirements&#8230;the Act imposes current burdens and must be justified by current needs.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, dissenting: \u201cThrowing out preclearance when it has worked and is continuing to work to stop discriminatory changes is like throwing away your umbrella in a rainstorm because you are not getting wet.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Rewriting the nation\u2019s story, Trump and his appointees have moved to alter the contents of displays in Smithsonian museums and national parks. They have used their power to make multifront attacks on a wide range of American institutions that hold the government accountable and provide safeguards against tyranny: accomplished private law firms; major media outlets; large foundations; and leading universities, Harvard most prominently. They have disrupted some of them to the point of upheaval and exerted unprecedented government influence over how they operate.<\/p>\n<p>In late September, District Judge William Young \u201962, LL.B. \u201967, had scathing words for the Trump administration in a case about efforts to deport noncitizens who had engaged in pro-Palestinian speech. (One of the plaintiffs was Harvard\u2019s chapter of the American Association of University Professors.) Young, 85, a Reagan appointee and a onetime chief counsel to a Massachusetts Republican governor, called the freedom of speech case \u201cperhaps the most important ever to fall within the jurisdiction of this district court.\u201d<\/p>\n<p class=\"callout\">Emergency cases have come to preoccupy the justices\u2014and have reoriented how the Court shapes American law and life.<\/p>\n<p>Young acknowledged \u201cthe rapidly changing nature of the Executive Branch under Article II of our Constitution and, while he is properly not now a defendant in these proceedings, the nature of our President himself.\u201d He stated, unequivocally, that the Trump administration had misused the government\u2019s \u201csweeping powers\u201d to violate a First Amendment right that extends to noncitizens. And he said, in a footnote, that \u201cthis gambit has been accompanied by the Trump administration\u2019s full-throated assault on the First Amendment across the board.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Almost a century ago, a Supreme Court opinion by <a href=\"https:\/\/www.harvardmagazine.com\/2019\/04\/supreme-court-holmes\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr.<\/a>, A.B. 1861, LL.B. 1866, LL.D. 1895, defined \u201cthe principle of free thought\u201d at the heart of American democracy, which is the foundation of American law protecting free speech and the free press from government suppression: \u201cnot free thought for those who agree with us, but freedom for the thought that we hate.\u201d Trump and his administration seem to be taking dead aim at obliterating that principle and to be embracing its opposite.<\/p>\n<p class=\"text-align-center\">* * *<\/p>\n<p>When the Court hands down its final \u201cmerits\u201d decisions each year\u2014after considering legal briefs and listening to oral arguments, and after a lot of deliberation\u2014that\u2019s widely considered to be the end of the annual term, even though the official end is not until the start of the next term on the first Monday in October. An exclamation point invariably comes in the form of a summer blockbuster ruling, such as Trump v. United States in 2024.<\/p>\n<p>This past June, the exclamation point was <a href=\"https:\/\/www.supremecourt.gov\/opinions\/24pdf\/24a884_8n59.pdf\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">Trump v. CASA<\/a>, an \u201cemergency\u201d case that arose from judicial injunctions against the executive order that Trump issued the day he was sworn in as president against the time-honored understanding of birthright citizenship.<\/p>\n<p>A decision about an emergency case comes from the part of the Court\u2019s work sometimes called \u201cthe shadow docket,\u201d because it is much less transparent than the merits docket. Generally, those cases get decided quickly\u2014without much briefing, without oral argument, and without an opinion explaining the decision. The orders are ostensibly provisional but, in many instances, they prove final.<\/p>\n<p>\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission, 2010<\/p>\n<p>Result: The Court unleashed dark money in politics when it ruled that corporations should not be treated differently from \u201cnatural persons\u201d under the First Amendment. Roberts had laid the groundwork for the ruling in a previous opinion where he equated campaign finance regulation with suppression of speech.<\/p>\n<p>Roberts, in a concurring opinion in Federal Election Commission v. Wisconsin Right to Life, Inc.: \u201cWe give the benefit of the doubt to speech, not censorship.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Justice John Paul Stevens, dissenting in Citizens United: \u201cThe Court today rejects a century of history when it treats the distinction between corporate and individual campaign spending as an invidious novelty.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Emergency cases until recently were rare in civil matters, used chiefly in criminal cases involving death sentences and imminent executions. The administration in office seldom brought them: the George W. Bush and Obama administrations together brought a total of eight in 16 years. The first Trump administration changed that norm, bringing 41, and the Biden administration brought 19. In its first 20 weeks, the second Trump administration brought 20. (By late September, it had brought 28.) Emergency cases have come to preoccupy the justices and take a lot of their attention. They have reoriented how the Court shapes American law and life.<\/p>\n<p>CASA was only the fourth emergency case in more than half a century that the Court considered in oral argument. The case addressed the legality of the nationwide, or universal, injunction, which a trial judge in a single federal district court had the option of imposing throughout the United States against an executive order or other form of law.<\/p>\n<p>Over the years, nationwide injunctions have been frustrating to administrations of both parties, which tend to argue they are imposed with partisanship. But while the Court had previous opportunities to address their lawfulness, it had declined to rule\u2014until now, in a case that cut to the heart of American identity and rested on a legal precedent that went back more than a century and a quarter.<\/p>\n<p>Section 1 of the Constitution\u2019s Fourteenth Amendment says, \u201cAll persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.\u201d In 1898, the Court affirmed birthright citizenship as \u201cthe ancient and fundamental rule of citizenship by birth within the territory\u201d: if you\u2019re born in America, unless you\u2019re the child of a foreign diplomat, you\u2019re an American.<\/p>\n<p>Trump\u2019s executive order\u2014the opening salvo of the administration\u2019s anti-immigrant campaign\u2014says the 1898 ruling was mistaken for allowing citizenship in certain situations involving a parent who was not legally permitted to be present in the U.S.<\/p>\n<p><img decoding=\"async\" alt=\"Group holding banner reading \u201cBirthright Citizenship Is a Constitutional Right.\u201d\" data-entity-type=\"file\" data-entity-uuid=\"5c846294-6a62-4b0a-9133-6021a98662d6\" height=\"1333\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/hm_10.6.25_trump-casa-protest.webp.webp\" width=\"2000\" loading=\"lazy\"\/><br \/>\nTrump v. CASA, the subject of an emergency ruling this summer, arose from Trump\u2019s efforts to change the time-honored understanding of birthright citizenship. | Photograph by Jim Watson\/AFP via Getty Images<\/p>\n<p>In its CASA decision, by a 6-3 vote along ideological and partisan lines, the Court severely limited the use of nationwide injunctions. The majority opinion by Justice Amy Coney Barrett did not grapple with the merits of the Trump administration\u2019s argument about birthright citizenship; instead, it said this was a likely improper form of relief for anyone beyond the parties in that single lawsuit, and that a collective case should generally be handled through a class action suit.<\/p>\n<p>In a concurring opinion, Justice Brett Kavanaugh encouraged the government and other parties to continue to file cases on the emergency docket and asserted that, in the sometimes-years-long interim between when an emergency case is filed and the Court rules on its constitutionality, the nation needs a unified answer on enforcement\u2014and the Court should provide that answer.<\/p>\n<p class=\"callout\">Like the Trump decision, the CASA decision affected the balance of power among the three branches.<\/p>\n<p>Injunctions issued in lower courts after the CASA ruling have kept the anti-birthright citizenship order from going into effect, because a patchwork approach to birthright citizenship\u2014some states having it, others not\u2014would cause confusion and burdens in states not allowing it. The administration\u2019s slow response to those injunctions suggests it expects its attack on birthright citizenship to fail.<\/p>\n<p>Still, like the Trump decision before it, the CASA decision affected the balance of power among the three branches\u2014severely limiting a tool of lower federal court judges to block even blatantly unconstitutional policies of the government. It was built on the Roberts Court\u2019s maximalist view of presidential power.<\/p>\n<p>Other decisions the Court has recently made from the emergency docket show how much the Roberts Court has enabled Trump\u2019s swift expansion of power. The decisions, often overturning lower court rulings, have had enormous, sometimes catastrophic, consequences: removing noncitizens to countries to which they had no ties; disqualifying transgender service members; firing probationary federal workers; firing members of the National Labor Relations and the Merit Systems Protection Boards; firing more than 1,000 workers at the Department of Education and dismantling the department; releasing reams of personal data to the Department of Government Efficiency, a White House initiative; allowing immigration raids in California, based on racial and ethnic profiling.<\/p>\n<p>In September, the Court granted a Trump emergency request to withhold $4 billion in foreign aid that Congress had appropriated. The order, while noting it reflected a preliminary view, said the president\u2019s power to conduct foreign affairs outweighs the potential harm to those designated to receive the aid.<\/p>\n<p>Kagan, in a dissent supported by the other liberal justices, emphasized that the Trump emergency application raised novel issues about the relationship between the president and Congress. The Court should have waited to address them on the merits docket, she said, with the guidance of opinions from lower courts, full briefing, and oral argument.<\/p>\n<p>In July, in a panel discussion at the National Constitution Center in Philadelphia, the legal scholar Stephen Vladeck, who in 2023 published The Shadow Docket: How the Supreme Court Uses Stealth Rulings to Amass Power and Undermine the Republic, had explained the logic behind the Roberts Court\u2019s decisions: Emergency relief is based on the view that the party requesting it is likely to win on the merits. Until that victory, it will suffer irreparable harm without the relief. The government suffers irreparable harm whenever one of its laws, including an executive order, is blocked.<\/p>\n<p>But, Kagan pointed out in her dissent about the refusal to pay foreign aid, the administration had not shown it was likely to win on the merits. It had not shown it would suffer irreparable harm without the relief granted in the order. It had not \u201cmet our standard for emergency relief.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>In each recent emergency decision for the Trump administration, the order in question, once in effect, did irreparable harm to some or all of its targets. Those rulings, Lawrence Hurley <a href=\"https:\/\/www.nbcnews.com\/politics\/supreme-court\/supreme-court-trump-cases-federal-judges-criticize-rcna221775\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\">reported<\/a> on NBC News in September, have left some lower court judges appointed by Republican and Democratic presidents, who worked \u201cpainstakingly\u201d to apply the law as it existed and were overturned, feeling frustrated and betrayed\u2014undermined and abandoned by the super-majority of the Supreme Court. \u201cIt is inexcusable,\u201d one judge told Hurley about those justices. \u201cThey don\u2019t have our backs.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>In a dissent from the CASA ruling, Justice Sotomayor echoed her complaints about the Trump ruling a year earlier: \u201cThe Court\u2019s decision is nothing less than an open invitation for the Government to bypass the Constitution. The Executive Branch can now enforce policies that flout settled law and violate countless individuals\u2019 constitutional rights, and the federal courts will be hamstrung to stop its actions fully. Until the day that every affected person manages to become party to a lawsuit and secures for himself injunctive relief, the Government may act lawlessly indefinitely.\u201d<\/p>\n<p class=\"text-align-center\">* * *<\/p>\n<p>Throughout his two decades as chief justice, Roberts has looked to historical role models for guidance and comparison\u2014from the clear-eyed approach to justice embodied by his early mentor, Henry Friendly, to the human qualities of his former boss and predecessor, William Rehnquist, whom he called \u201can extraordinarily good and decent man.\u201d Prominently, Roberts has also cited the legacy of John Marshall, the legendary chief justice from 1801 to 1835, as a practitioner of principled and pragmatic jurisprudence.<\/p>\n<p>But the Marshall-Roberts comparison isn\u2019t entirely apt. Marshall was aligned with a political regime out of power\u2014he was a Federalist, at a time when the nation was divided between Federalists, who favored a strong national government and a commercial economy, and anti-Federalists, who favored a limited national government and an agrarian economy. A month after he was sworn in as chief justice, Marshall swore in the anti-Federalist Thomas Jefferson as president\u2014and spent much of his almost 35 years on the bench trying to resist or reckon with a contrary regime in power.<\/p>\n<p class=\"callout\">\u201cThe Court\u2019s decision is nothing less than an open invitation for the Government to bypass the Constitution.\u201d\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"callout\">\u2014Justice Sonia Sotomayor, dissenting in the CASA case<\/p>\n<p>Roberts is positioned more like Marshall\u2019s successor, Roger Taney, who was chosen by, and generally on the same side as, the regime in power during his 28 years as chief.<\/p>\n<p>Taney has been ranked among the country\u2019s great justices by professors of law, history, and political science, as the historian Walter Ehrlich wrote in the Oxford Companion to the Supreme Court of the United States. In his long tenure, Ehrlich wrote, Taney \u201cpreserved and refined the main lines of Marshall\u2019s constitutional law, opened economic opportunities for many Americans, and retained a strong national power redefined to accommodate a judicial dual sovereignty\u201d with that of each state.<br \/>\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>Rucho v. Common Cause, 2019<\/p>\n<p>Result: Federal courts, including the Supreme Court, lack the power to review partisan gerrymandering because that presents a political question.<\/p>\n<p>Roberts, for the majority: \u201cFederal judges have no license to reallocate political power between the two major political parties, with no plausible grant of authority in the Constitution, and no legal standards to limit and direct their decisions.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Kagan, dissenting: \u201cThe partisan gerrymanders in these cases deprived citizens of the most fundamental of their constitutional rights: the rights to participate equally in the political process&#8230;[they] debased and dishonored our democracy.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>\u00a0<\/p>\n<p>But that\u2019s not how most people know of him. Taney is infamous for inflaming America\u2019s bloody division over slavery and for making the Civil War inevitable. As Ehrlich wrote, \u201cEven though he saw nothing positive about the institution of slavery itself, Taney withal was a southern gentleman imbued with southern values, and here was an opportunity to settle the issue.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>In the Dred Scott case of 1857, Ehrlich summarized, the \u201csouthern and proslavery\u201d majority of the Court, with Taney writing its notorious opinion, ruled that Black people couldn\u2019t be American citizens; that the Constitution regarded slaves as property; and that each state where slavery was lawful could decide if an emancipated person could be made a slave again. The decision and the opinion made Taney a pariah and gutted the authority of the Court.<\/p>\n<p>In his confirmation hearing, Roberts called that decision \u201cperhaps the most egregious example of judicial activism in our history,\u201d with \u201cdisastrous consequences.\u201d After the ruling in the Trump case, though, some progressive commentators reacted by declaring that Roberts is as contemptible as Taney, based on a comparison of the Dred Scott and Trump decisions and their arguably similar shattering of the American republic. The commentary illustrated deep agitation about Trump and his dominance. It was part of what Roberts called \u201cthe personalization of judicial politics,\u201d whose harm to the Court he worried about early in his tenure.<\/p>\n<p>A fatalistic way to view Roberts\u2019s intentions has taken hold in the first year of the second Trump term. Some legal observers contend that the conservative majority has exercised prudence in many of those emergency rulings, by engaging in Roberts\u2019s method of judicial self-protection. By issuing a procedural decision in favor of the administration, the reasoning goes, the majority put off a difficult reckoning. It avoided the risk of issuing a substantive order that the president would defy, creating a full-blown constitutional crisis. As the legal scholar William Baude commented in The New York Times in July, \u201cEven if you wanted the court to maximally stop the Trump administration, surely it would need to pick and choose its spots carefully. There\u2019s just too much lawlessness to do otherwise.\u201d<\/p>\n<p><img decoding=\"async\" alt=\"President Trump shakes hands with Justice Roberts in the Capitol rotunda\" data-entity-type=\"file\" data-entity-uuid=\"fb64655b-4f38-42da-b41d-9107c2543708\" height=\"1333\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/hm_10.6.25_president-trump-roberts-handshake.webp.webp\" width=\"2000\" loading=\"lazy\"\/><br \/>\nAfter his presidential swearing-in ceremony on January 20, 2025, President Trump gestures to Roberts in the Capitol rotunda. | Photograph by Chip Somodevilla\/Getty Images<\/p>\n<p>Outside the circle of professional Court watchers, though, the self-protection, if that\u2019s what it has been, looks like partisan support for the Trump administration. It looks as if the Court is forsaking its checking function in the system of checks and balances and using its power in service of the Trump agenda. After the CASA ruling, many judicial observers remarked on how, through its emergency docket, the Court was often ruling for the Trump administration without explaining why\u2014rule by edict in place of rule by law.<\/p>\n<p>The legal scholar Rogers Smith wrote in The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science in June, \u201cIn a country deeply divided over constitutional conservatism, Roberts\u2019s tenure as chief justice has led to the opposite of what he has said he seeks to achieve. The American public now respects the Court less than ever and sees it as more political than ever.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Twenty years ago, in his speech against Roberts\u2019s confirmation, then-Senator Obama recounted a conversation with Roberts from the day before. Roberts, Obama recalled, had told him that \u201che doesn\u2019t like bullies and has always viewed the law as a way of evening out the playing field between the strong and the weak.\u201d Knowing that his \u201cnay\u201d vote wouldn\u2019t halt Roberts\u2019s confirmation, Obama offered a wish for the future: \u201cGiven the gravity of the position to which he will undoubtedly ascend,\u201d he emphasized, \u201cI hope that his jurisprudence is one that stands up to the bullies of all ideological stripes.\u201d<\/p>\n<p>Trump, to many, personifies the bully Obama warned about. His assault on democracy has tested Roberts\u2019s institutionalism in ways the chief justice seems not to have anticipated, or not to have wanted\u2014or been able to lead\u2014the Court to constrain.<\/p>\n<p>As a singular American figure, the 47th president might have a singular effect on Roberts\u2019s legacy. That\u2019s why the Trump opinion looms so large. It would be a tragedy for Roberts if his long tenure as chief justice were reduced to that single ruling and opinion because the portents of doom in the Sotomayor dissent prove accurate in the extreme\u2014and turn what Roberts meant as the solution to a problem of constitutional governance into a license for autocracy.<\/p>\n<p>It would also be a tragedy for the Supreme Court and for the United States. This is a moment in the nation\u2019s history when the need for a strong and respected Court is acute. But the Trump ruling seemed to embolden the president to further stretch the bounds of the Constitution\u2014and each new decision in Trump\u2019s favor erodes public trust that the Court will constrain him.<\/p>\n<p>Ensuring that the executive respects the rule of law is the ultimate test Roberts may face. Suppose the Court orders the president to end a policy because it violates the law\u2014a policy Trump deems essential to his cause. If the Trump decision and the Court\u2019s loss of public legitimacy lead the president to think he has the power to disobey that order, what safeguard against authoritarianism will be left?<\/p>\n<p>In a landmark decision almost 75 years ago\u2014striking down an effort by President Harry Truman to seize and operate most of the nation\u2019s steel mills\u2014Justice Robert Jackson wrote famous words in a concurring opinion about the Supreme Court\u2019s duty to constrain a president who disobeys the law: \u201cWith all its defects, delays and inconveniences, men have discovered no technique for long preserving free government except that the Executive be under the law, and that the law be made by parliamentary deliberations. Such institutions may be destined to pass away. But it is the duty of the Court to be last, not first, to give them up.\u201d\u2001<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"John G. Roberts Jr. \u201976, J.D. \u201979, has written hundreds of Supreme Court opinions in his 20 years&hellip;\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":209117,"comment_status":"","ping_status":"","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[18],"tags":[23,3,21,19,22,20,25,24],"class_list":["post-209116","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","category-united-states","tag-america","tag-news","tag-united-states","tag-united-states-of-america","tag-unitedstates","tag-unitedstatesofamerica","tag-us","tag-usa"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/209116","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=209116"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/209116\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/209117"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=209116"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=209116"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/us\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=209116"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}