In my first months at what is now DTN\/The Progressive Farmer, back in 2003, I was asked to speak on China at a farmers\u2019 meeting in Iowa. I wasn\u2019t an expert on Chinese agriculture but, having lived and worked in Tokyo and Hong Kong for 17 years, I had witnessed China\u2019s remarkable economic development. I felt confident pronouncing, \u201cChina is the difference between $5 soybeans and $10 soybeans.\u201d<\/p>\n
It wasn\u2019t a bad call, at least directionally. Within a few years, sales to China were rising and soybeans were ranging from $9 a bushel to well into the teens. Thanks to China, US soybean exports have doubled since I gave that speech.<\/p>\n
For many years now China has been our soybean farmers\u2019 biggest overseas custome<\/a>r \u2013 by a large margin. In 2024, China accounted for more than half of American soybean exports. The next largest customer, the European Union, accounted for only a tenth. In up years and down for US exports, China\u2019s lead has been large.<\/p>\n Some of the down years began with China\u2019s retaliation for the tariffs President Donald Trump imposed in 2018. Since then, China has increasingly turned to Brazil as its preferred supplier. Still, it has continued to buy a lot of US beans.<\/p>\n Until this year, that is.<\/p>\n As every soybean farmer knows, Trump has hit China with big tariffs once again and China has once again retaliated. In this year\u2019s first eight months, the Chinese bought only 200 million bushels, down from a billion in the same period last year. In recent months they bought none.<\/p>\n Farmers are fearful. The president of the American Soybean Association, Caleb Ragland, said<\/a>, \u201cThe farm economy is suffering while our competitors supplant the United States in the biggest soybean import market in the world.\u201d<\/p>\n At some point \u2013 hopefully before a lot of soybean farmers start declaring bankruptcy \u2013 China will buy US beans again. Foreign Agricultural Service staff in Beijing think there will be purchases in the first half of this marketing year, DTN Contributing Analyst Mike McGinnis reported<\/a>.<\/p>\n That prediction was made before China put new controls on exports of rare earths and Trump responded by imposing additional 100% tariffs on everything China ships us. Hopefully these moves are negotiating tactics that will eventually be rolled back. But who knows when.<\/p>\n Trump had promised to talk to China\u2019s President Xi Jinping about soybeans and, assuming there\u2019s a ceasefire in this latest volley, he still might. But that isn\u2019t the only reason to hope for some sales.<\/p>\n There\u2019s also the possibility that Brazil and Argentina won\u2019t be able to supply all of China\u2019s needs. Moreover, US beans may prove price competitive, assuming retaliatory tariffs are dropped. Finally, it\u2019s in China\u2019s continuing interest to buy from a variety of suppliers and not rely exclusively on preferred supplier Brazil.<\/p>\n Grateful as they\u2019ll be to have China buying again, soybean growers should have learned something from this latest battle in the US-China trade war: They\u2019re too reliant on China. In the years ahead they\u2019ll either need to find new markets, domestic as well as international, or plant fewer acres.<\/p>\n China, for its part, is determined to reduce its reliance on us. It\u2019s spent years helping Brazil expand production<\/a>. It\u2019s working hard to increase domestic soybean output by increasing acreage and improving yields. It\u2019s even investing in Russia to boost that country\u2019s soybean production.<\/p>\n This doesn\u2019t mean the Chinese will never buy from us. They just want enough alternative sources of supply that we can\u2019t hurt them badly by cutting them off. They realize embargos are always a possibility given the ups and downs of US-China relations.<\/p>\n By the same logic, we need to develop enough alternative markets that the Chinese can\u2019t hurt us as much as they\u2019re hurting us now. That will be a herculean task. We\u2019re dangerously overdependent. The $12.6 billion in beans China bought from us in 2024<\/a> was more than the combined purchases of the next nine customers.<\/p>\n There isn\u2019t another China waiting in the wings. India\u2019s population is larger, but India bans genetically modified imports and protects its farmers with a 57% duty on non-GMO beans.<\/p>\n Indonesia is both the world\u2019s fourth most populous country and, in 2024, the fourth largest export market for US soybeans. But its purchases totaled $1.2 billion. At 2024 levels, it would take 10 Indonesias to make up for the loss of China.<\/p>\n The billions in compensatory payments the Trump administration has been talking about would be better than nothing but they aren\u2019t a substitute for sales. Farmers need stable customers they can build plans around.<\/p>\n What the government needs to be working on, hard, is helping the industry develop additional markets, lots of them, domestic and foreign, while also helping increase sales to current customers.<\/p>\n If China finally makes purchases this year, those purchases will, for some farmers, mean the difference between just getting by and catastrophe. What farmers need is to have enough other markets that China sales are the difference between a good year and a great year.<\/p>\n Former longtime Wall Street Journal Asia correspondent and editor\u00a0Urban Lehner<\/a>\u00a0is editor emeritus of DTN\/The Progressive Farmer.<\/p>\n