Campbell Gulbrandsen, a fashion assistant living in New York City, says she was on the creatine wave “before it got super popular” online. The 24-year-old first heard about creatine on social media, where it was being promoted by fitness influencers doing highly demanding sports, like bodybuilding and marathon training. But it wasn’t until she saw it being taken by more casual exercisers – the Pilates princesses – that she decided to give it a try. The brand she opted for was Arrae, which sells creatine in gummy form. “The branding definitely roped me in,” says Gulbrandsen. “They’re cute flavours and the whole thing is that it tastes good … It’s very female-oriented.”
Once primarily advertised with blocky typefaces and images of men with bulging muscles, creatine supplements, which have existed since the 90s, have recently shifted their focus to female consumers. That’s been made obvious through a shift in the supplement’s visual identity, with Goop-esque, pastel-coloured options like Midi, Flo and Cymbiotika entering the market. Alongside the sleek new branding, the nature of the products has changed too. Not a fan of giant tubs of powder? You can now chew your creatine in the form of gummies, drink it from squeezable packets, or slap it on via topical patches. Within the past year, the supplement’s aesthetic facelift has been accompanied by a swell of social media content, in which UGC wellness creators rattle off everything creatine has done for them, from toning their muscles to alleviating their brain fog.
The rebrand isn’t subtle. New female-centred brands, like Fit Git Creatine, are continuing to enter the market. “What we wanted women to feel when they first saw it was that it was something they could see themselves using right away,” says creative director Olivia Vlachos, whose agency has led the new product’s marketing and design. The supplement, which launches early next year, comes in hot pink sachets and flavours like pink lemonade. “Branding is how someone encounters a product,” says Vlachos. “If you’re walking down the aisle at Erewhon, are you going to pick it up?”
The marketing efforts are working. Searches for “creatine monohydrate for women” are up 190 per cent compared to this time last year, according to Google Trends, and on Amazon, sales within the creatine subcategory have surged 90 per cent over the last 12 months, according to SmartScout marketplace data. With creatine market size projected to reach $8.7 billion by 2033, growing at nearly three times the rate of the global dietary supplements market, the numbers are clear – the boom is real. But what exactly is behind it?
This content is hosted by TikTokTo view this content, you must allow TikTok to set cookies and load third-party resources.Load TikTok
Answering that question requires an understanding of where creatine comes from, and what it can and can’t do. Creatine is a compound that comes from amino acids and supplies energy to the muscles. “[It’s] something that our bodies naturally make from three amino acids, and it’s mainly created in our liver and kidneys,” says Yasi Ansari, a sports dietitian based in California. “Having more creatine in our muscles can allow us to do more short and intense work in the gym, on the field, on the court, and over time, this results in more gains in our strength and our muscle,” she adds.
While creatine has long been taken to build muscle, more and more people are now reaching for the supplement to promote brain health. But is there any validity to these claims? Experts believe it’s too soon to say. Although a few small studies have shown that large doses of creatine can slightly increase brain activity, the research isn’t conclusive, and, as Ansari says, “the jury’s still out” on the supplement’s cognitive benefits.
On social media, however, the concept of creatine’s brain-boosting abilities has gained traction, making it one popular reason people are clicking “add to cart”. Hana El Sherif, a 25-year-old finance associate, for example, began taking creatine after a friend told her it could help with sleep and cognitive function. “One thing I liked about creatine is that it almost felt like a multivitamin,” says El Sherif. “It ticks so many boxes, and you get all these benefits you otherwise would have to get from four or five supplements.”
Grace McHugh, a 24-year-old living in New York City, also started taking creatine because of its potential cognitive benefits. Her primary reason, though, was for marathon training. Though her college boyfriend took creatine every day, it was female influencers who got her to start – she decided on the brand Promix after reading a profile on the brand’s founder, an extreme athlete turned wellness entrepreneur. “I do think there’s an increased interest among women,” says McHugh.
“In the 2010s, it was all about women trying to lose as much weight as possible. Then, we saw a complete shift in how women think about workouts, as muscle mass became something that people started to value more”
There is clearly a connection between the rise of creatine and the fact that, in recent years, more women have taken an interest in building strength. “In the 2010s, it was all about women trying to lose as much weight as possible,” says brand strategist Katie Klencheski, whose marketing agency SMAKK Studios specialises in health and wellness. “Then, we saw a complete shift in how women think about workouts, as muscle mass became something that people started to value more.”
It’s true that the popularity of strength training, which can be especially beneficial as we enter menopause and lose bone density, has been on the rise among women. But aside from increased awareness about menopause, Klencheski also points to the explosion of GLP-1s, which can cause muscle loss, as a reason for the current preoccupation with strength. “You have a lot of people on GLP-1s who are barely eating any food, and the muscle wasting thing is a very real concern,” says Klencheski. “A lot of people are looking for ways to stop that.”
This content is hosted by TikTokTo view this content, you must allow TikTok to set cookies and load third-party resources.Load TikTok
Aside from eye-catching packaging, brands are partnering with influencers and UGC creators to spread the good news of creatine to the masses. As with other supplements, though, this can get murky because, as Klencheski notes, the regulatory system around this content is “a little bit like the Wild West”. In the US, supplement companies can make certain claims about how a product affects the structure or function of the body, provided those claims are substantiated and not misleading, but they cannot market supplements as diagnosing, treating, curing or preventing disease.
The lack of regulation of the supplement market is especially important to keep in mind when it comes to creatine, given that much of its current online buzz is being fuelled by creators using language like “body-changing” to promote its powers. “Everyone thinks they’re going to take creatine and magically transform their body solely from the supplement,” says Anna Hellickson, a 23-year-old living in Los Angeles. Hellickson started taking creatine in March, but, sceptical of the gummies and drinks she saw marketed towards women online, opted for an old-school unflavoured version. “I don’t need the fun version, just the benefits,” she says.
Though the irresponsible claims by influencers don’t negate the fact that creatine has legitimate, science-backed benefits, Ansari says that it “cannot be a substitute for good nutrition”. While some of the online commentary has veered into problematic territory, many women feel that the overall movement is still about getting stronger rather than shrinking, which is a step in the right direction. “We’ve been in this skinny trend for a good amount of time now, and I think that creatine is helping propel this next stage of body image norms,” says Hellickson. “Strength is coming back.”
Still, it’s not exactly the case that the creatine boom is the antithesis of diet culture. While creatine may have once been viewed as something for more extreme fitness enthusiasts, in a health landscape where DIY peptide stacking has become normalised, it’s perhaps not surprising that there’s a new sense of openness around the supplement. And with that openness, or “white space,” as a marketer would call it, comes a readiness for the wellness industry to do what it’s always done: sell, sell, sell.